duendy, I've read your "materialistic dogma" rants with some interest. I must say that I understand what you're saying and why you're saying it, but, in the end, isn't it the responsibility of the individual to decide whether or not they want a materialistic lifestyle?
If my family on the reservation get tired of going outside for water, should they deny themselves plumbing for their hogan because our ancestors used the act of obtaining water as a ritual?
Should small pox have been allowed to spread among my ancestors because they didn't have the natural immunity that the Europeans developed and vaccination wasn't a traditional response?
I agree that there's more to life and living than science can readily explain, but I also admit that science does a bang up job in my life. I meditate and listen to music that suits my mood. I seek smells and aesthetic things in my home that give me peace and tranquility. But I also take ibuprofin when an old knee injury swells after a long run and get my flu shot each year. I find a happy medium between modern science/medicine/technology and the aesthetic and comforting aspects of tradition. I smug my house with sage and sweet grass from time to time, but mostly because I like the smell more than because I think it will actually keep 'spirits' away (it also gets rid of the cigar odor in my car).
I think you have some good points about materialism, but I also think you go way overboard in your rants. After all, this is a "Science" forum, and it is expected that most, if not all, discussions would be "scientifically" slanted.
Finally, I think you may be the proof we need that telepathy DOES exist. Maybe you aren't using a PC at all for your posts and do it by THINKING them to the internet! That might explain the spelling mistakes (I'm kidding, of course... I remember reading some time back that you have a small keyboard).
Yenald Looshi
If my family on the reservation get tired of going outside for water, should they deny themselves plumbing for their hogan because our ancestors used the act of obtaining water as a ritual?
Should small pox have been allowed to spread among my ancestors because they didn't have the natural immunity that the Europeans developed and vaccination wasn't a traditional response?
I agree that there's more to life and living than science can readily explain, but I also admit that science does a bang up job in my life. I meditate and listen to music that suits my mood. I seek smells and aesthetic things in my home that give me peace and tranquility. But I also take ibuprofin when an old knee injury swells after a long run and get my flu shot each year. I find a happy medium between modern science/medicine/technology and the aesthetic and comforting aspects of tradition. I smug my house with sage and sweet grass from time to time, but mostly because I like the smell more than because I think it will actually keep 'spirits' away (it also gets rid of the cigar odor in my car).
I think you have some good points about materialism, but I also think you go way overboard in your rants. After all, this is a "Science" forum, and it is expected that most, if not all, discussions would be "scientifically" slanted.
Finally, I think you may be the proof we need that telepathy DOES exist. Maybe you aren't using a PC at all for your posts and do it by THINKING them to the internet! That might explain the spelling mistakes (I'm kidding, of course... I remember reading some time back that you have a small keyboard).
Yenald Looshi