This and that
Grim Reaper said:
I think if a person kills someone then they inturn should be killed in the same manor in which they killed the person. What I mean by that is if a person kills someone by dragging them behind a vehicle then that person derserves the same. And I think it should be done in the public for all to see. To get the message out if you choose to do this then this is what you get.
Beyond Spidergoat's point about the imperfection of guilt as relates the general proposition—any individual case notwithstanding—the supreme law of the land in the United States of America has a specific prohibition against this sort of thing. It's called the Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution, and reads, quite simply:
Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.
(Legal Information Institute)
And, besides, every once in a while, that sort of eye for an eye just won't satisfy people. Some murders are, as murders go, as kind as a murder can be. In those cases, I can imagine that some of the eye for an eye advocates wouldn't be satisfied with so peaceful an end. So even if we threw out the Eighth, there would be some who just weren't satisfied.
• • •
"Joey, have you ever been in a ... in a Turkish prison?"
A general note on American prisons and the Constitution
For some reason, we still call prisons the "correctional system", and some of us still remember the word "rehabilitation". And while the idea of rehabilitative or correctional prison seems something of a joke in these days of overcrowding to the point of warehousing inmates like livestock, the reality is that no matter how vengeful some of you might feel toward those who break laws of any severity, this is the United States of America, and we're simply not running the legendary "Turkish" prisons. See the Eighth Amendment, quoted in the prior section of this post.
____________________
Notes:
United States Constitution. 1787. Legal Information Institute at Cornell University Law School. October 1, 2009. http://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/constitution.overview.html