Medicine*Woman said:
----------
M*W: Bells, you hardly fit the description of a martyr at the stake! What gives? You do realize, I hope, that all those 9 million women who were tortured and burned were good Christian women. Why would your dad, uncles, and cousins set YOU afire? I'm missing something here!
LOL I was being sarcastic.
Lucy
Yes you are very correct in a way. Having travelled to Asia I too noticed that the men there were more apt to approach women dressed in western clothing. However, most of the local women also wore the same clothes I was wearing. The tour guide and the hotel staff informed us that the local men treat the western women that way because for them it was ok to do so because we weren't from there, we weren't local women. While I was always careful to dress in a manner that would not be deemed to be offensive to the locals, just the fact that I was not from that part of the world meant that it was basically an open ticket to harrass or touch. The only time we felt safe was when our local tour guide was with us. It was also the same when I went back to Mauritius for a holiday. They could pick that I was not from there, even though I was born there and spent a good part of my childhood there, but apparently to them it was obvious that I was not 'from' there per se, so they took it as normal to harrass and approach me on the street, especially if I was walking alone. So to reduce any risk to myself, I never walked on the streets alone and always had a male relative or friend accompany me. They never did the same to any of my female relatives who lived there, because they lived there. I dressed in the same way that everyone else did. In fact I dressed more conservatively than most of the locals regardless of the heat, in a bid to attract less attention. Although even that did not work. I was later told that it was not how I dressed but because it was obvious that I did not live there. So it was the kind of thing of harrass the women who weren't from their country or lived in their country, but it was ok to harrass women who came from elsewhere.
Proud Muslim
In 2000 in Sydney (Australia) a young Australian girl was gang raped by 25 Lebanese men in their late teens and early 20's. This rape was racially motivated in that they called her a christian pig and aussie slut. She had been coming home on a train from a job interview, dressed fairly conservatively. On the security video on the train, it showed a couple of these men approaching her and chatting to her on the train. She was then kidnapped from the train station and taken to a vacant factory where the rest of the gang arrived after having been sms'ed and called from mobiles and this girl was then gang raped and brutalised in a manner that even had the police officers investigating the crime cry on national TV. During the rape she was called a christian slut and aussie pig repeatedly and also other names. She was then hosed down by the rapists and taken to another location and raped again. After these men were caught and tried, the Australian public were up in arms. The crime was one of the most vile crimes committed here against a young girl who had done nothing wrong except be an Australian non-muslim. Muslims across the country were horrified. The Lebanese religious leader in Sydney called for the men to be sent back to Lebanon to face the death penalty as all they would get here would be life imprisonment because these men had committed an act so vile against another person. Further investigation later showed that up to 7 women were gang raped around that time. I have no time to do a search on articles on this issue, but it is well documented and many articles are available on the matter.
Other articles you might find of interest are:
http://www.hraic.org/rape_and_islam.html
http://www.afrol.com/Categories/Women/wom003_violence_unfpa.htm where it stated:
Molestation of young girls is another profoundly disturbing aspect of this problem. A study in Zaria, Nigeria, for example, found that 16 per cent of hospital patients with sexually transmitted infections were under age 5. At the Genito-Urinary Centre in Harare, Zimbabwe, doctors discovered that more than 900 children under age 12 had been treated for a sexually transmitted disease in 1990 alone.
Yes I'm sure these young children were dressed soooo provocatively.. And then it went on to say this:
Throughout the world, perhaps as many as 5,000 women and girls a year are murdered by members of their own families, many of them for the "dishonour" of having been raped, often as not by a member of their own extended family. Many forms of communally sanctioned violence against women, such as "honour" killings, are associated with the community's or the family's demand for sexual chastity and virginity.
In Egypt, a father paraded his daughter's severed head through the streets shouting, "I avenged my honour."
Charming!
And just as frightening in that article was this:
At least one in every three women has been beaten, coerced into sex, or abused in some other way, usually by an intimate partner or family member, according to a new report by the United Nations Population Fund, UNFPA. In Africa, domestic violence, rape and other sexual abuse and female genital mutilation are of special concern.
Documenting the extent of the problem, The State of World Population 2000 report says that gender-based violence constitutes a life-long threat for hundreds of millions of girls and women around the world. Gender-based violence - in various forms including rape, domestic violence, "honour" killings and trafficking in women - exacts a heavy toll on mental and physical health. Increasingly, gender-based violence is recognized as a major public health concern and a serious violation of basic human rights.
The problem seems worst in Asia and in the Muslim world. However, African women are subject to a range of oppressive threats.
Could it be PM that the reason that there are less reported rapes in Muslim countries is due to the fact that under Muslim law, there must be 4 men present who can corroborate the rape of the woman or else the woman can be charged with adultery? Could that be one of the reasons why so few rapes are reported in muslim countries? After all, most rapes take place where there are no witnesses to the crime.
It is such a common occurence in the Muslim world that, although the vast majority of Muslims abhor it, it barely registers a protest. Simple-minded and patriarchal interpretations of Sharia law in countries such as Pakistan, Sudan, Malaysia, and Nigeria are punishing Muslim rape victims for the "crime" of being raped, due to the equating of rape with zina, or extramarital sex. The latest incident involves 26-year old Zafran Bibi of Pakistan, who, after reporting a rape (with the child of said rape in her arms), was unable to produce four male witnesses of the crime and was sentenced to death by stoning for zina. This follows the recent death sentence (which has since been commuted) confered upon Safiya Hussaini Tungar-Tudu in Nigeria under similar circumstances. While the punishments for so-called hudood crimes are rarely carried out, hundreds of women who have reported rapes are held in jail under these laws. These latest cases have increased the debate in Muslim countries about the application of hudood punishments and calls by Muslim scholars and women's groups for their repeal or reform. "With the men, they apply the principle that you are innocent until proven guilty," said Asma Jahangir, an official of the independent Human Rights Commission of Pakistan and the author of a book on hudood. "With the women, they apply the principle that you are guilty until proven innocent."
http://www.altmuslim.com/gender.php
PM it is obvious that your education (or lack of) has taught you that women who dress in a western style and who may show some skin are provoking the rape. It is sad that you could think that. However, you still have shown no real proof for it, only opinions that mirror your own. And even if your opinion be true, why should women change the way they dress because men can't handle it? Why don't men change their attitudes or curb their urges? Why is it that we women have to pay for men's lack of self-control?
I would also like you to answer these question. Why is it that men are also raped? Are they dressed too provocatively as well? Why are babies raped? Is it because some pervert saw their bare bottom during a nappy change and was provoked? Your argument is unfounded on just these questions PM. It is not only women are raped, but men, boys, girls, babies, the elderly. How do you contribute your argument to these victims of rape? Or is it that you follow the true sharia law in that a woman is to blame for the rape if she has no male witnesses to support her claim? Because your whole argument seems to be pointing in that direction. You're basically stating that the man is not to blame for a rape but the woman because she may have asked for it in the manner of her dress. You're a sad creature PM and frankly, I have only pity for you and for the women in your family.