For those of us who are Atheists here, I thought to ask whether any of you can provide a philosophical argument that demonstrates the impossibility of god. That is to say, not simply "the lack of evidence for god", but the logical impossibility.
Come, we must have some strong atheists and non-agnostics here, so I expect you to come out of the woodwork and show us where the Theists are wrong.
This ought to be interesting.
heres a few to get on with
If god is moral then everyone has a chance to enter heaven. This means people who never learn which religion is correct, or even accept the wrong religion, have a chance at entering heaven. Our moral actions must determine whether or not we enter heaven, not our knowledge or religion therefore revealed religion must be false.
If god is all-powerful and all-good, it would have created a universe with no suffering and no evil. But, evil and suffering exist. Therefore god does not exist, is not all-powerful or is not benevolent. Attempts to justify the existence of evil are called theodicies. There are no fully working theodicies, even popular ones such as the free will theodicy were rejected thousands of years ago for reasons that still stand today. It seems that if there is a god, it is not the all-good moral being that classical religions would have us believe
"Introduction to the problem of evil" by Vexen 2000 Jan 22
Is there a god?
Is there a point to life before heaven?,(
these ai'nt questions to be answered, just points, put forward)
If god wants what is best for everyone it could immediately place everyone in heaven. If we want what is best for our children, we could kill them, and then god would send them to heaven because they were innocent.
Because we do not do this means that there is no god, no heaven, or that there is some purpose to life and evil. However, there is no such purpose.
Babies who die (for example, in natural disasters) go to heaven, therefore there is no essential point of life, nor any essential reason that we have to endure suffering and go through the tests of life before we can go to heaven. This shows no god exists, especially a moral god.
"Killing babies" by Vexen 2003 Feb 08
Three reasons to reject god:
1. As god has historically served as a force for evil and it seems that any Demon could very easily trick us into thinking it is god we must reject all feelings and thoughts from god for fear of us being deluded.
2. The major monotheistic religions hold that idolatry is a serious sin so it is safer to accept no god rather than risk accepting the incorrect one.
3. The goal of reaching heaven is dubious as we know very little about what heaven is really like. In conclusion:
If god is just, moral or understanding it will forgive us our cautiousness! If god is not just, moral or understanding then we hardly want to share heaven with it for all eternity.