jayleew said:
So, is that why the more we take God out of things the worse things are getting?
Yes, temporarily. Religion has been such a part of our very being for so long (from the first thinking human's first fear and un-answered question), that when some of us challenge the established order of things, religious zealots get defensive because they cannot think, or will not think, for themselves for a change. It is much easier to deny than to analyze. Analysis takes much hard work, whereas denial takes very little comparatively.
How can you say that the world would be better, kinder, and more peaceful?
Call it a hope more than true knowledge. I have seen first-hand what religion, and thus God, have done to our world. How can you not see it? I just hope there is a better answer.
It would be the opposite.
I don't think so.
If there is nothing to live for, than you are living for yourself.
Better, imo, to live as yourself, than as an ideal that is un-achievable in this life.
Without a belief in a higher power, everything you decide to do, whether it is to help granny across the street, or shoot up drugs, it is what you want to do.
Are you saying that believers in a god are perfect? Are you saying that it is better to give some "god" credit for the good I do than it is to give myself a little credit now and again? I don't have the answers, but I'm not claiming to. Sometimes I like to think I do, and I have to beat myself up-side the head when I do, but I don't have all the answers. Neither do you, or anyone else, imo.
If I didn't believe in God, I would be doing a lot of immoral things, some legal, some not.
How do you know? Have you tried it without God? I've tried it both ways, sincerely, and I have found that without God is better for me
and for those around me. Still, not perfect, imo, but better. At least now I see a light for me at the end of a very dark tunnel.
I would still care for people and be a good person, but I would still stab my brother in the back if it there was enough profit involved to do so.
That is a sad, theist perspective. Try telling god to fuck off for once. Go ahead, I know it's scary, maybe, but not such a bad thing. I wasn't struck down by lightning.
It is naive to assume that without religion the world would be better.
It is more naive to think that god has done any good in this world.
People are not peaceful by nature, if you look at human history.
A human history dominated by gods, sure.
We would be vengeful people with the eye-for-an-eye attitude, or worse.
Where does the eye-for-an-eye concept come from again?
Just truthfully search yourself, and you know that if the price was right, you could be bought.
Probably. Are you saying that you have never been bought? Has your god helped you to become perfect already? Things are not black and white, as you probably think.
If the circumstances were right, you would act in an immoral way that you would normally not act.
Give me a "for-instance" please.
In short, without a belief in a superior state of existence, we would be animals, without the ability to defy all the instincts that come with being an animal because we would not have a reason to defy the basic instincts.
We would still have all the same exact HUMAN reasons to not act like an animal. You think a human without a higher power can't see the causes and effects of his/her actions? You think that if I say there is no god, that I am automatically blinded to the fact that if I pinch some girl's ass, she will not possibly get angry. She could get angry because it hurt physically. I could understand this, and I would probably learn something from the experience. Some might not, but that is no different than the way things have been for thousands of years with all the gods of the world. You give yourself too little respect, and this is a symptom of religion saying we are worthless without a higher power. We are not. You should respect yourself more and god less.
We would have nothing to live for, but today.
Yes, but would you not want to make today better? Tomorrow even better. I would, and am, without god. You can do it too, if you want to stop the suffering in the world that is created by intolerance and division. We will never be perfect, so we shouldn't expect it of ourselves, we shouldn't place so much emphasis on attaining it, but accepting this makes it easier for me to be better to myself and to others.
And you are optomistic of human behavior, if not naive, if you think that is a good thing.
I hope so.
If you need an example look at our society that doesn't believe in God. Specifically, anyone who has a lot of money, popular, and without God.
Most of the people I know that have money, are popular, etc., do claim to have god.