Everyone should choose truth over their child.
The 'truth' is that I love my child more than anything.
Does it even make logical sense to say that I should choose the truth that I love my child over the fact that I love my child? I'm unsure what you're getting at.
Anyway, because you made the assertion. Why should I?
If your child was a serial rapist, would you hand them over to the cops? Or would you pretend nothing was going on?
It's an interesting question in that people that become serial rapists/killers etc typically have some serious underlying problems. Who are we really blaming? Sure, we put them in prison but it's not because of them, it's because we're trying to protect everyone else from their illness.
Of course you said 'serial' which - to me at least - certainly implies a serious underlying issue that isn't their fault. Having said that, although I deal with people that have such problems, I could be completely wrong and they could just be doing it because there's nothing better to do on Sundays. If you've seen English TV on Sundays you might just concur.
Ultimately I wouldn't, (and I doubt any loving parent would), be 'turning them in' because I thought they deserved punishment, but because they needed help, (the fact that we can't help to any great degree is beyond the point).
Unfortunately your question doesn't provide enough detail. For what reason am I phoning the police? To make them suffer or to prevent everyone from suffering, (hopefully including themselves)?
You don't need to abandon the good people for heaven, only the ones who don't make the grade.
Let it be said that "the grade", (as most christians seemingly perceive it), includes those that simply failed to have a belief in said entity. In either case, that is not a statement of 'love', it's a statement from the man that couldn't be bothered ensuring his loved one got the needed help.
That you'd abandon anyone actually sickens me. You have my oath that should I find myself in heaven and you find yourself in hell - should I have the ability, I will take the time out to rescue you from your suffering. I don't particularly like you very much but I'd still do it. You on the other hand would apparently abandon your own mother. I think that says it all.
You always hope they will change, but that does not mean you'll accept it when they are wrong
And - unless magic brain changing is the method in heaven, it will always bother you. What then is heaven?