Notes Around
A General Reflection
I switched back and forth between American (NBC News) and Canadian (CBC,
The National) coverage, which I sometimes forget a lot of my American neighbors can't do.
It was an interesting contrast, though the differences were perhaps subtle; the Canadians were sooner to reflect on the fact of politics, the number of times the president used the word "I", and so on.
Perhaps it's tomorrow's election, but our northern neighbors were giving much consideration to both the political implications and the bounds of good taste, especially as they counted down to PM Harper's brief address.
But on both sides of the border, some analysis has been looking at the emotional significance. The Canadians really played up how badly we took it on the chin in 2001, and how important it was to morale to have actually accomplished this goal. Rachel Maddow, talking via telephone from Lafayette Park with Brian Williams, reflected on the age of the crowd gathering there—mostly younger twenties—and the fact that the whole of their adult life has been shadowed by the spectre of Osama bin Laden.
It's a hard thing to celebrate a death. It's a harder thing to celebrate a killing. Indeed, we can expect American pacifists, and perhaps some conservative opponents of the Obama administration, to vociferously remind that the president essentially ordered a hit.
And, to be sure, Neil MacDonald of
The National asserted to host Wendy Mesley that despite what criticisms people might aim at American "imperial ambition", bin Laden was a war target, and this end was well within our right.
My own heart tugs at me tonight. This isn't an end point, but perhaps a new chapter. Still, though, nine years and seven months later—over thirty-five hundred days gone by—yes, we have reached this milestone. And it might well be set in blood, but be there a God to bless these United States, we might pray that, having felled this quarry, we might see tomorrow anew.
Yes, the spectre of Osama bin Laden has apparently been brought to its end. And, yes, the implications of how this war has passed its days are messy and will be long in sorting, but there is, in fact, a burden lifted from the hearts of Americans.
It is a small victory, but of nearly ineffable importance.
For a night, at least, we will celebrate, and remember how it feels to hope.
• • •
James R said:
In Obama's address he said that bin Laden was killed "after a fire fight". I hope he meant "during a fire fight".
Yes, this is a common phrasing in American parlance.
To the other, the standing order has been dead or alive; I doubt there are many among my American neighbors who ever thought for a minute that if we brought in bin Laden, we would bring him in alive.
• • •
Mrs.Lucysnow said:
And the flags? Where the hell did they get all those flags? I mean why do they have flags on hand for an impromptu celebration? Is there a flag seller who rushed to the scene along with the merry makers?
Well, to the one, we're Americans, so we have a striking excess of flags laying around. To the other, if you're referring to the scene outside the White House, well, it
is Washington, D.C. I couldn't give you an estimate of flags per capita, but if there's a college town around with more American flags than decency prescribes, it would be Washington.