Laughlin, Robert B. (2005). A Different Universe: Reinventing Physics from the Bottom Down. NY, NY: Basic Books. pp. 120–121. ISBN 978-0-465-03828-2.
I have not read the above. I did just download a sample from Amazon and will try to take a quick look at that sometime in the next few weeks. I will be out of the country for a while.
I do have a couple of questions for you though, referring back to the context issue I raised earlier.
Have you read any of his peer reviewed papers and research? And how do you see the above popularized book, within the context of any of that work?
As I mentioned before context is sometimes more important than a literal reading of the words. There is a big difference between condensed matter research and gravity. At least there remains a significant divide at present. And though there can be insights found in popular publications (lay oriented books), by noted physists, those popular publications are generally not peer reviewed science. At best they are genuine attempts to provide some lay oriented understanding of difficult theoretical subjects, discussions and questions. At worst they are lay oriented books addressing popular issues, for the purpose of economic gain. In many cases one can not tell which, based on the interpretation of the lay reader, who generally approaches the subject either with preconceived notions or insufficient background information.
I do not know you, but the subject matter of your post suggests you fall into the catagory of the poorly informed lay reader, with preconceived notations.
Not having read "A Different Universe", it is difficult to say what Laughlin's intent was, from where I sit. However, after reading some of what you have been preaching, it is also difficult to believe that you have not read the same with a prejudiced ear.