Write4U
Valued Senior Member
Don't wish to press any issue here, but AFAIK, Jesus was charged by the Pharisees, but declared innocent by Pilate. Without the insistence of the Pharisees, Pilate would have set him free.Ostensible crime. If the Romans had not been there, neither would have Pilate or the Pharisees: they would have had a Hebrew king and autonomous government, and prophets preaching division of state and church wouldn't even be possible, let alone popular
I don't quite see how this can be turned into a peaceful mob and a guilty Roman governor. Of course there are alternate motives by all but Jesus, but I don't see how any of these are the primary cause for the eventual murder of Jesus, except the results of exclusivity in religion.
It very much reminds me of Hypatia, an atheist, who was a respected teacher and mathematician and astronomer, but was literally torn apart by a mob of monks, for teaching science.
The other key player in Hypatia's demise is the Patriarch Cyril, the Bishop of St. Mark. He was installed as bishop in October of 412. It was his mission and his quest to bring Christianity to Alexandria, to rid the city of pagans and Jews. He fought his battle for Christian purity by moving against groups that did not follow his beliefs. Cyril was a power-hungry man, who was later canonized by the Catholic Church.
On one eventful day, some 50 monks came upon Orestes. One of them, Ammonius, threw a rock and hit him on the head. Ammonius was arrested, brought before Orestes, and tortured until he died.
At this point, Cyril made efforts to reconcile his differences with Orestes, but the prefect would have nothing to do with it. Cyril then turned his attention to Hypatia, blaming her for Orestes's refusal to reconcile.
http://www.womanastronomer.com/hypatia2.htmHypatia's denunciation is reported by Socrates Scholasticus. He says, "men 'of the Christian population' started to spread a slanderous rumor that Hypatia was the lion in the path to a reconciliation between the bishop and the prefect. It was astronomy that sealed her fate--understood, of course, as astrology alloyed with black magic and divination."
And stripped naked and literally torn to bits.
Everybody had a political or religious stake in this tragedy, but the innocent pays the price. Typical and reminiscent of all subsequent hysterical religiopolitical psychotic trials and deaths, regardless of guilt.
Last edited: