[
yes spanking and hitting are 2 different words
What are you doing when you spank someone?
This is the first paragraph after I did scroll down to the small part that advises for parents who will still spank their children:
By now you should realize that our position on spanking is simple: don't. But we are also experienced enough to realize that some loving, nurturing, committed parents believe in spanking as part of their overall discipline package. As a pediatrician with thirty years in practice, I am also quite aware that regardless of our advice against spanking, some parents are going to spank their children. For these parents, the best we can hope for is to help them spank in a way that is less likely to become abusive. Consider these suggestions.
It's still telling parents that they shouldn't do it.
Good link.
if the child didn't listen to what i was saying after all other options are used yes
But you didn't use all the other options, did you?
my parents did take balls away i found something else to do that i knew was wrong.
lets try your way and twist and patronize me for my beliefs
so you would take ever ball away from the child?
Yes. And I have often. I have also taken their lego away as well as their other favourite toys.
never once did i say tazer children your the one who keeps comparing children to adults
yes i know they are.. they should only be used when the officer is being over ran by the suspect and is unarmed. they are more for females i want to See a 130lb female take on an 260 built guy not going to happen. the taser evens the playing field and gives the officer the upper hand.. to be quite honest id rather get tasered 100 times then hit in the face with a baton
I am comparing them to adults because they are human beings, like adults are human beings. And yet, because they are smaller and are less mentally developed than adults, they automatically have less rights than adults. I am asking why that is?
again your talking about adults this topic is about children yet you keep bringing adults into it. if you touch me its assault if you touch your child its not
if you spank a child properly after all options are exhausted you explain to the child what they did wrong and pat them on the butt it is very effective
spanking or touching an adult is assault. spanking your child is not this has been said many many times i guess you just refuse to read it
But why does the adult have more rights and protection at law against "spanking" than a child? That is what I am asking and no one has been able to give an answer. Why is it assault for me to spank you but not to spank a child?
Why is a child less deserving of legal rights and protection enjoyed by adults?
yes its a violation between 2 adults 2 kids that but from parent - child not pulling pants down is not when did i say paddle hair brush wtf? and belt i never said to use any object i had them used on me yes i never said using an object once again twisting what I'm saying
Have you grasped yet, what this whole thread is about?
It is about schools using a paddle on a child. Or more to the point, a child who was paddled at a school.
if you give someone a high five your hitting them with force too. in the article i believe it was the parents who pushed for it.
Do you think it's right that they pushed for hitting their child with a paddle?
pointless argument STOP COMPARING CHILDREN TO ADULTS its not the same! now your comparing children to animals dogs are about as smart as a 2 year old thats about it and hitting any how is abuse why? because you can explain to the dog 100000000times why you did it he still wont understand your reasoning outside of maybe chewing crap he still wont understand why with a dog you physically close its mouth huddle over it and wait a min or 2 physically touching the dog to get the point across i want to see you train a dog without ever touching him or her its impossible
Okay. I'll make it simple for you.
1) "Spanking" an adult is deemed assault. Be it with a hand or paddle or belt or whatever a person uses to do the "spanking".
2) "Spanking" a dog is deemed animal cruelty. Be it with a hand or paddle or belt or whatever a person uses to do the "spanking".
3) "Spanking" a child is not deemed assault or cruelty towards that child. You can use your hand, paddle or belt and it would not be deemed assault.
Why is it illegal in the first two but not the third? Why is it illegal to spank an adult or even a dog, but not a child? Why does an adult and a dog have more protection at law than a child does against spanking?
No, reason is because they don't know what they are doing is wrong "depending on what type of disability is"
What of an adult who has the same mental capacity of a 7 year old?
it doesn't matter how many studies you have read quite frankly i don't give a fuck, I went through getting spanked it it has had no effect on me. and I'm sure theres millions more out there just like me. having gone Through it no amount of studies is going to make me believe that spanking has long term effects "if used properly" on the child I'm living proof of that and what were the symptoms of these long term effects? a study like that would need to take at least 20 years to complete
Some of the studies I have posted have been running for more than 20 years. Some have continued on from other studies.
Would you delegate and allow others to spank your children?
doing your best and not trying are 2 different things... I'm positive if your parents knew how smart you were and just flat out weren't trying or just enough to get by they would have taken action if not thats a parent failure in my opinion.
IE if you know your child is a B student and is getting all Ds
As my grade 3 teacher found out, "spanking" and hitting a child in a bid to get them to do better has the opposite affect. My mother was a school teacher and she knew that spanking a child to do better would more often than not result in the child doing worse.
its all HE, HE, HE this isn't about me alone its about spanking in general i don't appreciate you pointing the finger at me for my beliefs and millions of others feel the same way that i do if spanking is used properly its a great tool with 0 side effects i don't give a fuck what studies say im living proof of that..
Of course. And next time you are sick, you will not go to a doctor to ask for their expert advice, correct? Because you don't give a "fuck" about what studies or experts think on the matter.
I am a person who can tell you exactly of the detrimental affects of spanking or corporal punishment on a person's psyche. Do you know why? Because of the 'corrective' treatment I received from my grade 3 teacher and from having to sit there and watch as a grade 5 teacher used similar means against a deaf child for not listening. The damage it does to you mentally stays with you for life. One cannot see it on the outside, but it is there. You go to any jail and ask prisoners whether they were spanked as children and I can assure you, the greater majority of them will say yes. Their being spanked and corrected by their parents did not prevent them from turning to crime or being aggressive.
Studies have shown time and again that spanking has a higher chance of leading a child to be aggressive. To believe that violence is acceptable. I know you do not give a fuck what studies show, but that is what it is showing. Corporal punishment is deemed a human rights violation, did you know that? Why do you think that is? Why do paediatricians advocate against spanking? Why do psychologists and psychiatrists also advocate against spanking and advocating for making corporal punishment in schools, for example, illegal? Why do you think that is?
and finally i respect your opinion on spanking if you spank them great if you choose not to thats also great this whole debate is you attacking and not respecting me for my opinions when i respect yours. so instead of trying to call me out on examples trying to connect spanking with spelling personally attacking me how about you just talk about it in general. the only reason i put myself in the mix is because i was spanked and have had 0 side effects.. if my parents hadn't taken punishments to that level i wouldn't be as successful as i am right now. and no amount of studies you post will make me change my mind the fact is they are wrong all of them unless they put "in some cases"
I will tell you this. I respect you more for doing the spanking yourself than for delegating it to a 3rd party to do it for you.