9 whales vs a human... which one would you chose?

9 whales vs 1 human, which one will it be?

  • Save the whales, 9 living creatures vs one!

    Votes: 15 45.5%
  • Save the human, we must defend our species.

    Votes: 12 36.4%
  • I can't make up my mind.

    Votes: 6 18.2%

  • Total voters
    33
man... and I was expecting some heated debates between animal rights activists and umm.. non-animal right activists...

but I guess sci-forums is a peaceful place now.

Well, let's look at whales--they are some who say that the cetacean species (as a group) are at least as intelligent as Humans, but their intelligence takes a different form. Should we therefore regard whales as evolutionary equals, and give them equivelent human rights--i.e. stop killing them?
 
Pretend you have a chance to save 9 whales, or one human being... which would it be.

Assuming the 9 whales are perfectly healthy whales, and the human being is a responsible and admirable person.


PS: If you don't like whales for whatever reason just replace it with your favorite animal.


What I would do is to find a solution that saves them all. ;)
 
The whales

The whales.

I make this choice in specific protest of the proposition as being unrealistic and of slipshod construction.
 
The whales.

I make this choice in specific protest of the proposition as being unrealistic and of slipshod construction.

I would save the whales if I could keep them afterward. Whaling profits would be quite significant if I could breed them.
 
Survival of the twittest?

I tend to think whales and dolphins are smarter than humans, if only because they were smart enough to stay in the freaking water.

Then again, it might have been a bad choice, since we've made a point of punishing them for that decision.

Oh, look! We can harpoon a whale!

Yeah, that makes us smarter. Let me know the next time you see a whale freebasing.
 
I tend to think whales and dolphins are smarter than humans, if only because they were smart enough to stay in the freaking water.

Then again, it might have been a bad choice, since we've made a point of punishing them for that decision.

Oh, look! We can harpoon a whale!

Yeah, that makes us smarter. Let me know the next time you see a whale freebasing.

not all whales are good. Bottle nose dolphins(yes dolphins are whales) are evil fuckers. Like I said before they have high instances of gang rape and infanticide( and this they actually practice for on a species of porpoise).
 
Chimp booty?

PJdude1219 said:

Bottle nose dolphins(yes dolphins are whales) are evil fuckers. Like I said before they have high instances of gang rape and infanticide( and this they actually practice for on a species of porpoise)

The killings appear to be connected to food shortages, and the sexual behavior, while more mysterious, might have something to do with the flexible breeding capabilities of Bottlenose dolphins. Apparently, a hybrid Bottlenose/Risso's dolphin is a a curiosity to marine biologists, and the a Bottlenose/FKW offspring was born in captivity in 1985.

I mean, shit, if you could breed with other genera? I'm a human male; I'm horny enough as it is. I don't ever want hominini pan looking that good.

Or maybe I should just leave it at, "And ...?" After all, humans commit gang rape and infanticide fairly regularly. Never said dolphins were perfect. They were just smart enough to stay in the water and avoid opposable thumbs.
 

So I'm a pussy for trying to plan a way that saves them all, why would you say that? I like to solve problems and that would be one that would be a challenge to me to overcome. Why is it that we cannot do two things at the same time but must only choose to one thing or another?
 
You're just tying to compromise your way out of making a decision.
Come on man. Either harpoon the whales or splat the human!

At times like this, I think it helps to ask yourself:
"What would Kim Jong Il do in this situation"?
 
If he was a respectable and admirable person, he would sacrifice himself for the whales.
hell, that's what I'd like to do, but cynically, I don't trust myself.
 
At times like this, I think it helps to ask yourself:
"What would Kim Jong Il do in this situation"?


If I were Kim Jong Il I'd shoot myself for being the asshole he is to his own people. He makes the many starve while the military get everything they want. You think he is such a great leader why don't you move there with him?
 
I am trying to get there using £1 bargain air tickets.
I can get as far as Pau in France, but no farther.
 
the human. not that i don't feel bad for the whales, its just i consider humans a higher and more valuable form of life. although it may depend on the person. and the situation.

as for the baby tiger and the orangutan... well that is a harder decision because those are pretty darn cute haha :p
 
Back
Top