To some extent, that's what a democracy means.
To some extent, that's what a democracy means.
I'm so glad the US is not a democracy.
we're a republic which is kinda of like a democracy
There's nothing similar between the two. One is mob rule, the other is rule of law.
Norman Paech, former member of the German parliament
This was not an act of self-defence [by the Israeli army], but rather it was completely disproportionate - although we were counting on our ship being blocked and maybe checked.
This was a very serious offence, this was a war crime.
I personally saw two and a half wooden sticks which were used [by activists].
We had not prepared in any way to fight. We didn't even consider it.
No violence, no resistance - because we knew very well that we would have absolutely no chance against soldiers like this.
(more)Mohamed Vall, Al Jazeera reporter
The Israeli assault took those of us on the ship by complete surprise.
During that hour an half in the early morning everybody on board the ship thought that no-one would survive the Israeli attack because we saw about 30 war vessels surrounding this ship and helicopters attacking with very luminous bombs, the sound of them makes you think you are dead
That was a fear of war, complete war, on a ship that was full of men, women and even children.
The first soldiers on the ship were not killed, they were not shot at, they were captured by the defenders of the ship.
Moments later another bigger helicopter landed more troops and this time they fired immediately at people and killed as many as they could so that they could reach the cabin and take control of the ship.
I saw blood spilt on the ship and everyone knew that there was no weapons. we all knew the Israelis would intercept us and try to stop us, but we didn't think that they would open fire at the first moment.
I have been shown the picture of a Yemeni man, and this is ridiculous, who was on the ship and most people know that every Yemeni in the world has a Yemeni style knife, that is a cultural thing and does not have anything to do with violence.
I understand now that in Israel they are trying to make a big deal about that, saying that the boat was full of violent people and just because of that one man.
Anywho.. back to the topic..
Who wants to bet that in doing the security checks, everything will be wiped clean?..
If they return it at all. I guess Israel needs journalist equipment as much as they need land it seems.
Here is an article by Peter Rodgers, who is the former Australian ambassador to Israel. He makes some very good points, not only about the attack on the flotilla, but also about the supposed peace process and how Israel is portraying itself in the International community, most importantly, how the International community treats Israel and whether that support will or should continue..
Israel's folly may be the catalyst the West needs by Peter Rodgers.
\
C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\Desktop\4658972617_8413db8124.jpg
Handling APPx (0xe0) block.
Handling APPx (0xe2) block.
Handling APPx (0xed) block.
End of APPx data blocks reached.
Status = 0
Unable to extract some or all of the EXIF data, which may have been removed from the image file.
none of the images have any iptc or exif data as far as i can tell
Officials from the Customs Directorate said all passengers that boarded the Mavi Marmara ship were screened and that not a single passenger was in possession of any weapon. “Forty-two passengers boarded in İstanbul and 504 passengers got on the ship here. They were screened. We spotted no weapons and there is no such record in our logs. We did not notice anything suspicious about the Mavi Marmara. Had our officers had any suspicions, they would have reported it,” an official, speaking under the condition of anonymity, said.
http://www.todayszaman.com/tz-web/news-211621-no-guns-aboard-gaza-humanitarian-aid-ships.html
Can these Australians be dismissed as self destructive fanatics or martyrs?
Perhaps this incident will vindicate Palestinian suffering and demonisation.
In the words of Mr Rodgers:Is there any way to tell where the pictures were taken? Is there any way to scrub exif data?
The "weapons" cache I was referring to are the pictures here which source the pictures here
I'm surprised the pictures are still there.
The Free Gaza Movement aims to be an irritant for Israel. It says its mission was humanitarian, massaging the truth in a way that would do Israeli spin doctors proud. The flotilla was driven as much by the politics of the conflict as anything more high-minded. But politics, of the free-for-all shouting style, is what Israel claims to do best. How many times have you read about embattled Israel holding high a shining light of democratic practice in a sea of Arab darkness?
Precisely what danger did the flotilla pose to Israel? What was in their cargo that demanded such action in international waters? It seems knives and metal poles now pose a clear and present danger to the Jewish state. A state, we might note, that receives extraordinary amounts of military succour from the US; is now among the world's leading arms exporters and is the only country in the Middle East to possess nuclear weapons.
The footage on board the Mavi Marmara of the pro-Palestinian activists' efforts to thwart the Israeli boarding is being cited as proof of evil intention. The Israeli Defence Force claimed activists even tried to "kidnap" a soldier. Who was kidnapping whom?
http://www.smh.com.au/world/israels-folly-may-be-the-catalyst-the-west-needs-20100602-wzv8.html
In the words of Mr Rodgers:
Think of all those Hamas militants attacking the most moral army in the world [armed merely with tasers, stun grenades, tear gas and machine guns] with WMDs like marbles and slingshots
Haven't you read David and Goliath? They have a history of such violence.
Does the West force Myanmar to not abuse it's minorities? Does the West do anything effective about the killing in Congo. Even in Rwanda the West did not stop the violence.
Do you really believe the West would force Israel to do anything? Isn't it a bit naive to think that Arab terrorism is the reason the west does not do anything about Israel? Terrorism just helps the Western governments not have a public relations problem in the West while they do nothing about Israel.
Palestinians renouncing violence probably would be in there best interest because they aren't getting anywhere with violence anyway. Renouncing violence against oppressors goes against human nature but a battered wife does need to to know better than to hit back. This wife does not want to flee her ancestral home and nobody wants to let her live with them. The cops supports her batterer. These cops don't do anything for battered wives anyway unless the battered wive can bribe them with something.
If anything is going to be done about Israel individual people will have to do it. The flotilla is the sort of thing that needs to be done. Also boycotts will need to be done. Otherwise the next 40 years will be like the last 40 years.
Think of all those Hamas militants attacking the most moral army in the world [armed merely with tasers, stun grenades, tear gas and machine guns] with WMDs like marbles and slingshots
Haven't you read David and Goliath? They have a history of such violence.
Thats King David to you, buster.
You missed my point. I was telling why your suggestion that the Palestinians should not resist does not work as is proven by what happened to the peaceful Bedouins who did exactly what you suggest and now have no land.
As long as Hamas uses might against the Israeli
Nonsense, this is getting a bit stale. Israel chose not to even talk to HAMAS from the get go. HAMAS extended their hand right after the elections.
Right, now we are getting somewhere. The cause (gosh we don`t have a nation, it was taken from under our feet, we are pretty pissed off) is obviously a consideration for a solution (gosh, gee, lets talk about creating a nation for you, and perhaps consider lifting the blockade) and then compromise (gosh, OK, we will recognize Israel and gosh, OK we will give us SOME of the land we stole back to you) - HONEST and SINCERE dialogue.
Thus this board and my interest in such. Feel free to vacate whenever you want and focus on what interests you.
Without accountability, and consequences, the cycle continues. Tell me you can understand that?
You are sounding rather silly. The Israeli regime is flaunting basic human rights with its blockade. The reason? HAMAS. Who suffers. All Gazans regardless of who they voted for. This collective punishment is a flagrant abuse of human rights. I have said a zillion times, compromise is required from both sides, and I have said a zillion times, the Palestinians need to unite, reject violence, accept the reality of Israel, talk sincerely, and accept compromise in order to gain statehood and a future for ALL Palestinians.
Seriously? Hamas is so mighty?
Maybe the IDF saw that they only had "halfpint" size marbles and the activists had "boulders".I bet the IDF started shivering in their shoes when they saw the marbles.
Why should Israel deal with Hamas when Hamas hasn't changed its charter?