(Insert Title Here)
I don't think the rate of growth should be evidence for truthhood or falsehood.
In the end, while this is correct, it seems rather beside the point. After all, we just did endure a topic in which it was asserted that the problem of Islamic nations was that Islam was fundamentally defective in a way that other cultures aren't.
I think the topic title puts it very well. I've asked the same question of Islam's critics.
In general, it's not that Islam is above reproach, but that the people criticizing it the loudest don't seem to have much of a clue.
Some people around here should learn about what they fear. A rational fear is easily managed; an irrational fear can possess a person.
Look, I'm hardly an expert on Islam, but I do know that the reading I do on religions and similar social phenomena, as with politics, transcends common issues. I recommend for any non-Muslim (and, perhaps, Muslims as well) Martin Riesebrodt's
Pious Passions, which is a relatively recent (ten or twelve years old) attempt to examine religious fundamentalism in a comparative perspective. Beyond that, I've found that information on Islam available in the West falls into several broad categories:
-
Universally sympathetic pop scholarship: I'm actually a huge fan of this kind of literature because books like Armstrong's
A History of God or Pagels'
The Origin of Satan, or, indeed, Russell's books on the Devil, while presenting a highly-compressed tertiary examination of religions, leaves those who wish to move forward with diverse bibliographies to explore.
-
Evangelization and pseudo-evangelization: Whether it's Sheikh Nazim or the local chapter of CAIR, there seems to be an evangelical aspect about the presentation of Islam that irritates Westerners. Sure, God may be great, but twenty other religions tell me that daily, too. Dispense with the devotionals and let us see the results of Islam.
-
Ethnopolitik: You know, how did public discourse come to be accusation/counteraccusation? Oh, yeah ... relatively free markets. We've all seen FOX News, CNN, and the other newstalks ....
-
Radicalist: Enough with the explosions, already. You can martyr yourself with a rope in the privacy of your own basement. Oh, wait ... you don't
have a basement, do you? Garage? Ceiling fan in the parlor? Exposed hot water pipe in the bathroom? Come on, throw me a bone .... No, I said
throw ... oh, sh@t!
-
Internecene academic: Really this sort of stuff is more useful if I'm a Muslim, and it's hard to put myself through it just for the exposure to the mechanics.
-
Sufi vagaries: These are my favorite; they provide a link between what I get from other information sources and the inuitive. In fact, Sufi essays laden with vagary generally tend to address that link directly.
-
Fiction: Salman Rushdie ... um ... er ... I'm sure I've ... uh ... (damn)
Most of Islam's critics tend to focus on radicalist ethnopolitik without giving much consideration to other ideas. And yet, despite this focus, how exactly should we regard the fact that Islam is growing such as it is?
Zero ... can the second-tier hater routine. It sucks like a twelve year-old Ugandan girl.
:m:,
Tiassa