Holocaust Denial

Mr.Spock said:
dont shove the palestinians into this, they tried to exterminate the jews in 48.
Click to expand...
Yes after the Jews were invading and occupying their land. I can hardly blame them.

the quote is Einsteins, and he wasnt blaming the jews for not fighting back but everyone else for helping the nazis.
Click to expand...

The Jews should've fought back.
 
Norsefire said:
After the Zionist movement. You're conveniently forgetting that
Click to expand...

the zionist movement didnt invade anyone, they bought all of the land legally. it was arabs who started the violence from the start, even when jews offered them jobs.


Yes, now after tons of backup and aid...yet you didn't in the past
Click to expand...

who aided us in 48? we hardly had money to buy weapons, most of it was hand made.
 
Mr.Spock said:
the zionist movement didnt invade anyone, they bought all of the land legally. it was arabs who started the violence from the start, even when jews offered them jobs.
Click to expand...
The land was purchased legally, yes. However, that wasn't the reason you were invaded. The reason was because of the creation of the state of Israel; I can buy land in a nation without taking it over.
 
Norsefire said:
The land was purchased legally, yes. However, that wasn't the reason you were invaded. The reason was because of the creation of the state of Israel; I can buy land in a nation without taking it over.
Click to expand...

only there wasnt anything to take over.
 
Oh Lord! You are either unable to read or unable to understand but I fear most likely both. I tried to make it as clear as possible by posting the articles in full in the hope that you would read and understand them. Let me spell it out again:

The first article is about a libel lawsuit that David Irving brought against another academic who had questioned the historical accuracy and validity of Irving's 'research'. David Irving LOST HIS OWN CASE because HE ACCIDENTALLY PROVED that his work WAS INDEED historically inaccurate to the point of bare faced fabrications. David Irving was cuckolded by his very own libel suit. He showed the world his own arse. He then carried on with his holocaust denials in Austria and Germany before finally being arrested as reported in the remaining articles I posted here. In an attempt to avoid a trial he admitted that he wasn't an expert on the holocaust and that millions of people had indeed been gassed in concentration camps (depite the fact that he'd already seen the proof in that previous libel case trial a few years before).

All this was widely reported by press and media of all persuasions. I just googled it for you.....
Click to expand...

Ok, I'm did not and am not disputing that. Pray, tell me what I failed to understand.
 
Norsefire said:
I don't blame the Jews for the Holocaust. However, as the quote goes, "evil triumphs when good sits by and does nothing" or something like that.

The Palestinians fought back, the Native Americans fought back. Sure, the situation wasn't the same, but they fought back and the Jews should've as well.
Click to expand...

They did fight back when your isolated from the groups who would supply you its hard to get the weaponary to fight.
 
Mr.Spock said:
lock them up and throw the key. one holocaust is enough.
Click to expand...

Huwy said:
What about all the other genocides of comparable loss of life and atrocities?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_genocides

I see despite replies by others, you haven't edited your post to amend it.
What impression do you think that gives people? That you only think it matters when its people you care about?
Click to expand...

Mr.Spock said:
i dont see any reason to edit something i believe in, and i dont edit in general.

i think im not the issue here, i think the problem is you trying to blame me, for not feeling sympathy for the jews who were murdered in the holocaust, and that is very unfortunate.
Click to expand...

Ok, I think its fair since this is a thread on "Denial" to state that i'm not a "denier". Who are you saying feels no sympathy?
I certainly feel sympathy for ALL the innocent people killed in WW2, including from the holocaust.
My comment was ONLY in regards to your "one holocaust is enough" statement. Of course there was only one genocide referred to as "the holocaust" and I don't deny it happened, I'm just pointing out that by only referring to one (albeit one of the largest) genocides, some people (e.g. on this forum) get the impression you might not care so much about the others.

Maybe its human nature to care more about the persecution/murder of your "own people" or "tribe" than that of others?
 
Huwy said:
Ok, I think its fair since this is a thread on "Denial" to state that i'm not a "denier". Who are you saying feels no sympathy?
I certainly feel sympathy for ALL the innocent people killed in WW2, including from the holocaust.
My comment was ONLY in regards to your "one holocaust is enough" statement. Of course there was only one genocide referred to as "the holocaust" and I don't deny it happened, I'm just pointing out that by only referring to one (albeit one of the largest) genocides, some people (e.g. on this forum) get the impression you might not care so much about the others.

Maybe its human nature to care more about the persecution/murder of your "own people" or "tribe" than that of others?
Click to expand...

All [attempted] genocides are disgustingly vile outbursts of humanity at its worst.

When your grandparents were part of one, you feel closer connection to it naturally.
 
CheskiChips said:
All [attempted] genocides are disgustingly vile outbursts of humanity at its worst.

When your grandparents were part of one, you feel closer connection to it naturally.
Click to expand...

I can only imagine, but that makes sense.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top