(Q) said:
I swear I have read this exact same post from this exact same person at least 3 times.
It all sounds exactly the same because everyone is telling you the same thing. Perhaps you should start listening.
Let me give both of you something to think about.
We agree that Asian cultures are known for the practice of meditation. The practice of meditation is described as sitting quietly, usually on the ground. The stated purpose of meditation is to calm the mind and maybe for good health also. We all agree this is generally accurate.
When you sit down to meditate, what is going to happen? You will sit there and you will be bored. You are physically inactive. There is no way to release energy. Your only source of release would be mental activity. Or I suppose you could yodel or sing if we want to be accurate. Let's stick to the mind.
Your mind is going to go nuts. All the energy in your body is going into your head because you are sitting there doing nothing. You will think about work or your wife or the football game or what is for dinner. Meditation is recommended to be done for years for it to be effective. That means you are thinking about what is for dinner etc, every single day that you mediatate for 1 year or 3 years or 5 years.
At some point in your meditation practice, you will become intimately familiar with your thoughts. You know exactly what is going to be in your mind when you meditate. If you had a problem at work, you know that is going to pop up when you meditate. Or, after years of time, you will succeed in making your mind be quiet. You will have resolved all those thoughts that always clamored for attention, or you stuffed them away in a box so they do not bother you when you meditate.
For the purpose of this exercise your mind is blank after some years of meditation practice.
One day you go to the mini mart. You are in the mini mart looking for a soda. You get the soda and go to the counter to pay. As you do, you suddenly are struck by an impulse to steal a candy bar. You know that is not you. You are a person who is buying a soda. If you wanted a candy bar, you could just buy one. Because of your meditation practice, you know what kinds of thoughts are in your head. You have been watching them for years, and you know exactly what is in there. Stealing is not one of them. You never thought about stealing in your life.
Knowing this to be fact, you look around you. When you do, you see a child by the candy display. What would be a reasonable conclusion from this? For me, a reasonable conclusion is that the person in the story is picking up the thoughts of the child. He knows from his meditation practice exactly what should be in his mind. He knows that stealing has never been in his mind. He looks and sees a child right in front of the candy display.
Another person can say many other things are going on here. The adult in the story really was a thief or a million other things. That is not the point. The point is, Asian culture promotes meditation. That is fact. Meditation is supposed to develop the mind. That is fact. What is not accepted fact is that meditation would help a person develop telepathy. It seems like a reasonable possiblity. Telepathy would naturally fall under the category of mental development.
Then I would ask you to consider the case of mystics. If you search your memory, you will find that most depictions or descriptions of mystics is that they are solitary. They have many other characteristics. The solitary lifestyle is the important one for this. A solitary lifestyle would be similar to meditation. Solitude that forced the mind to develop because there was no outside stimuli.
If you string ideas like the 2 above together, the conclusions seem obvious. A person can say "That is not concrete fact or science" if they want to. They are only cheating themselves. There is a reason that human culture thruout recorded history has talked about telepathy and magic and mind powers. It is because there really are such things.