the day i become senile, i will go deep into science.Sounds like you have a paper to write and get peer-reviewed then.
but these days i am wandering what to do with this life.
this circumcision has least to do with HIV. the people are uneducated,poor, that should be main concern, so they don't go on having sex with any one mindlessly.I do think it is a cultural thing and one based on how the penis looks (religious reasons aside of course).
I've heard of men in the US having their son's circumcised so that their penis look the same. I'm sorry, but I don't personally see that as a valid reason. It would be akin to having a baby girl's nipples 'done' to look like her mother's, for example, or plastic surgery to her vagina so that it matched her mother's. And in Australia, cosmetic circumcision of baby boys or male infants is banned in public hospitals and quite a few private hospitals as well.
From a religious standpoint, there are inherent dangers in how that is performed in certain religious ceremonies.
My sons have never had a UTI. Until their foreskin can be retracted naturally and without force, there is no reason to retract it. If you try to force it, it can actually damage a child's foreskin. In short, they do not have to retract it for years. If they wash normally, that is all that is needed.
As for lowering the risk of cancer to the penis. Some claim that the foreskin can become cancerous, so they argue that removing it reduces the risk of that form of cancer. I am yet to see anyone argue that baby girls should have their ovaries removed and their cervix removed for a similar reason. You're not going to hear it because it would be an insane reason.
But in the case of penile cancer and increasing the risk of cervical cancer in women if they have unprotected sex with an uncircumcised male, one of the factors in penile cancer is hygiene. And if you do not wash yourself properly and wash away the smegma, it can irritate the foreskin, which can lead to cancerous growth. Again, hygiene. Then you have issues which are medical where the foreskin cannot retract properly and becomes inflamed and also injuries to the skin or soft tissue around the penis can increase the risk of penile cancer.
As for cervical cancer, the washing can increase the risk of HPV.
My ex-husband is not here, obviously. But yes, it comes down a lot to hygiene. Once the boy is old enough and able to retract his foreskin easily, then he can be taught to wash it with water.. Before then, just washing externally is all that is needed and trying to retract the foreskin too soon can actually cause permanent damage and inflammation.
But penile cancer is very rare in developed countries. But in 3rd world countries, the rate is higher. It's still rare, but it is higher than in developed countries. And also, because of the lack of protection while having sex, especially in 3rd world countries, circumcision is also touted as being helpful in preventing the spread of HIV - as it reduces the chance of contracting it from unsafe sexual practices according to some studies conducted in some countries in Africa... And this is where the waters become even murkier..
It's become a big deal because of some studies that were conducted about 10 years or so ago, which ended up recommending that males in some African countries be circumcised to reduce the spread of HIV.
In countries where access to water to wash, in developing countries for example, where being able to clean one's genitals properly may not be possible, male circumcision is touted as being necessary and encouraged to prevent a multitude of problems.
The studies that were conducted were themselves flawed and exceptionally unethical and frankly, endangered men and women alike. There was an article written in 2011, which discussed the African HIV studies and the claims that circumcision reduced HIV spread and it goes through and details every flaw in the studies themselves and it is an astounding read: http://www.salem-news.com/fms/pdf/2011-12_JLM-Boyle-Hill.pdf
men with intact penis cant hurt women by pounding, without getting their frenulum torn.
Last edited by a moderator: