Yeah but we're talking about slavery.
What's wrong with it, from athiest pov?
jan
What do you think a slave would think was wrong with it?
Yeah but we're talking about slavery.
What's wrong with it, from athiest pov?
jan
Given that the slave traders of the 17th and 18th century were god fearing christians, what is wrong with slavery from the religious pov?
Where in your Bable does it say slavery is wrong? In fact, doesn't your 'good book' give instructions on the proper attitude of slaves toward their master?
Yeah but we're talking about slavery.
What's wrong with it, from athiest pov?
jan
"And as ye would that men should do to you, do ye also to them likewise."
Luke 6 v31
quite simple really - as you would like to be done to, do it yourself!!"And as ye would that men should do to you, do ye also to them likewise."
Luke 6 v31
I don't think you've ever answered a single question put to you.
You just shuck and jive.
It removes another human's right to make choices for themself.No I'm not.
But let my ask YOU a question;
What is actually WRONG with slavery?
jan.
It removes another human's right to make choices for themself.
That doesn't explain why it's wrong?
Why is it wrong?
jan.
If it's not obvious that people should have the right to make their own choices, then I'm going to have to assume that your conscience is defective.This still begs the question: Why is that wrong?
So you won't answer my question then?
jan.
See? You've always answered a question with a question, and never supplied an answer.
Are you a bot by any chance?
Because it's exploitive. Labor doesn't get to keep their share of the wealth, and they have no personal right to liberty, freedom, happiness, even the right to be with your own family.
If it's not obvious that people should have the right to make their own choices, then I'm going to have to assume that your conscience is defective.
You know what a conscience is, right? It's that little voice inside your head that tells you when you're doing something you shouldn't do. I understand that some people do not have one of those - they are usually referred to as sociopaths.
Others tell me that that little voice is the voice of god... Personally I think it sounds more like my mother.
It typically boils down to the oft quoted "golden rule". You know, treat people the way you want them to treat you. It's not perfect, but it's a damn good start.
It's a simple 'do as you would be done by' rule of thumb.
Yeah but we're talking about slavery.
What's wrong with it, from athiest pov?
jan
But it's natural right?
Somewhere in our evolutionary past we must have developed this propensity. Right?
How can it be WRONG or right, for that matter?
The strong dominating the weak, better for the long term survival of civiliasation, no?
Survival of the fittest, natural selection, and so on..
Natural - as in "occurring in nature"? If you're looking for an objective reason, I can't give you one. But empathy is a part of nature.Is this not natural?
So, are you one of those people who doesn't have a conscience?Little voice inside your head eh!
Those folk are usually referred to as schitzophrenics.