Jan Ardena:
Recall that your initial claim was that angels are not supernatural beings, and specifically that they are "subject to natural laws".
I, and others, pointed out that the descriptions of angels have them doing things that are seemingly impossible according to natural laws. Moreover, the description of angels as "heavenly beings" or "messengers of God", along with various other characteristics, puts them squarely in the category of supernatural beings.
Who says they can or do fly?
Well, I thought you did.
Are you saying angels can't fly, now?
Maybe some of their species can , and some can't.
I see. So, let's concentrate on the ones who can, if we're going to talk about flying angels. Makes sense, doesn't it?
I'm saying that flying is not contrary to the laws of nature.
That's a fairly obvious statement, isn't it? We have birds and planes, for instance, which I think we can both agree are natural.
I have pointed out that an angel, as commonly depicted as a being that looks like a human, with or without wings, would have no "natural" means of flying.
If you can think of how such an angel could fly by natural means (other than in a plane or otherwise mechanically assisted, obviously), please tell us all.
I was never claiming that angels weren't supernatural creatures from our everyday perspective, only that they don't do supernatural things. Not according to what I've read.
Flying without some physical means of keep you up in the air is a supernatural act.
I was never claiming that angels weren't supernatural creatures from our everyday perspective
Oh, I thought that was
precisely the claim you were making.
So we can agree now that angels, as supernatural beings, are not subject to natural laws, contrary to what you originally claimed?
As for how they do it (if they do it), I don't know.
Maybe they don't even exist, so it's not a problem and you don't have to worry about it.
No I'm not an expert on angels James.
Indeed, you seem to hold simultaneous contradictory views about them.
If they exist as created beings, then they must have physical bodies.
Even though they are supernatural? Why so?
They can make their bodies disappear from our vision, at will. Not disappear completely. If they could do that they would cease to exist.
Where do angels live when we can't see them?
I've already given a couple of ideas how they could possibly do that, and you rejected them.
I must have missed your ideas. Could you please list them again, briefly?