Okay so this is a converstation I had over facebook with a person that I used to go to church with, but since then I've seen the light and embraced agnosticism.
well thanks for sharing, really nice material discussed, but first, the main issue:
yeah that's what pissed me off, that she actually pretended to be friends so she could try and convert me...like honestly who does that?
friends do that.
if you believed hell exists, and non christainswill get tortured there for ever after death, and you had a friend who wasn't a christian, and you really really really cared for that friend, what's the first thing you'd do?
if you came across an atheist who you don't give a damn about, would you care enough to preach them?
2-weren't you preaching HER????
and doing it so fricking good she couldn't wait to correct the mistakes se had in the last message to send it and get rid of you?
your questions and theories put her in serious doubt..her, a devout christian, from one who she was trying to save, who is now pulling HER into hellfire with him, who wouldn't listen to what's good for him and is trying to doom those who care for him, makes sense to run away when faced with hard questions..
also did you see the way she reassured herself that "i don't worship my version of god"?? you got into her man
, you screwed her up from the inside out..also mentioning studying psychology and the bible..wooo..you evil mastermind..
I may not have all the facts...but it's coz i KNOW what i believe and i don't believe God expected us to be rocket scientists to figure it out!..and you say "well you should know the facts?" well you yourself just said to me "why do i need to know where i come from"...i do...but i dont think i have to know everything about everything...
............
............
.............
Me:
You need to know the facts that back up your belief.
I need to know the facts that back up my belief. However my belief does not require me to know where I come from. That is the core of being agnostic, not knowing. If I claimed I knew something, I would have to show how I knew it. I do not claim this, so I do not need to show this. You however claim this and need to show it.
no you don't.
it's as simple as that.
not being able to show and prove something doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
if a kid can't prove hydrogen has one electron then it doesn't?
in book that tells you not to?
I know you think that without God everyone is evil. But there is nothing that proves this. A person's desire to do good or evil is determined by their genetics and their environment. This has been shown many times in psychological research. A persons' nature is not determined by a mystical being in another dimension.
with all due respect, this is bull..
What it all boils down to for me. Is that Christianity is a hypothesis answering the question of why are we here? It says we are here because God is so loving that he wasn't happy with what he had and needed to show that love to others. However these others rebelled against him and so he showed more love by killing himself. But not really himself but a man version of himself, that was only part of himself but that was actually not just part of himself but actually his whole self so he died but didn't die because it was only part of himself but died fully because it wasn't just part of himself and then he was raised from the dead therefore paying for all the rebellion that the people had done and now all we have to do is believe that part of God died for us and rose again, while believing that all of God died and rose again, and has forgiven us, in order to take part in salvation. And salvation is in another dimension called heaven. Where there is the son the father and the holy spirit who are all seperate gods but who are all the one god, and we get to spend all the rest of eternity in the presence of these gods/god and that's our reward for believing that god died.
i cracked up when reading this:roflmao:
and uh, i think the agnostic hypothisis should jump back a few step and start over..
The agnostic hypothesis states that: we haven't seen a god, we haven't talked to a god, we don't know if he actually exists, but we know there's a world, so something must have caused it, it's probably something that happened in this dimension that obeys the laws of this dimension because all we have ever seen is this dimension and things that obey the laws of this dimension, so it's too much of a stretch to say something in another dimension caused it. And in this dimension we see things like big bangs and evolution as being possible so that's probably the cause of creation rather than something that isn't based on any observable evidence.
how can you call yourself an agnostic when you've already decided what i underlined??
you're a full-fledged atheist bro..
Anyway I believe Jesus and his followers were mentally ill.
because they saw, talked to, and believed in god?
hoola hoop reasoning..
I've seen schizophrenics in real life claim the same sorts of things as Jesus and believe totally that they were true.
did they raise the dead?
talk as babies?
then you ask for the facts it's all based upon?
and mess your poor friends' brain?: D
I use parsimonious logic when deciding what I believe. Which means believing the simplest and most logical explanation.
So if I go to the fridge and find an apple in it, I do not believe that the apple came from another dimension through a worm hole created by aliens. I will jump to the simplest and most logical explanation, that my girlfriend must have gone to the shop and bought apples and left them in my fridge.
and that's what your friend meant when she said "see god all around you"..
all the equilibrium constants in the world, all the ones which only a little, what does it say?
bang a women and get the most advanced and complex "device" n the world, whithout any of you knowing anything or intervening with it, what does it say?
the skies, the mountines, all the pretty living beings, our suitible surroundings...
for most people;
my girl friend bought the apple = god did it.
However simple logical thought does not always dominate. In ignorance superstition plays its part. As can be seen in many behavioural experiments with animals. Birds for example were given food randomly. After a few days the birds started behaving oddly. One would peck at the corner of the cage, another would spin in circles, another would fly backwards and forwards. Why? Because the birds thought that these actions were what was giving them the food. They though 'hey I was spinning when I got food, so I'll spin again'. Of course it's all just random.
if you had no girlfriend, and the apple still apears in your fridge still, what would you think?
and loooooooool.....isn't spinning around and batting your wings the equivilant to scientists' evolution theory to where the "food" came from? as opposed to "god did it"?
what happenned to your simple reasoning?
It's much like christian belief. They believe and something happens, for example they pray and get the job they prayed for. So now they believe in prayer. Except this new belief is not falsifiable, meaning it can't be proved wrong. Because when they next pray and don't get something they want, there is an explantion, that they didn't pray with enough faith or what they were praying for wasn't in their best interest. But as long as the random rewards from time to time remain, their belief will also. In this random rewarding environment extinction of a belief is impossible.
they live longer.
they live happier.
their beliefe ranges from time to time, and they notice the difference, the same difference.
And like you said, the God you know isn't a God you can know from reading in books. Which is the real hook with Christianity. Because for each Christian God is tailor made to their own values. You have some christians who know God as a judge who hates homosexuals, and coincidentally they themselves hate homosexuals. You have other Christians who know God as all loving, and coincidentally they value love. You have other Christians who know God as a 'cool dude', and coincidentally they themselves value being 'cool dudes'.
is that true about christianity? what god wants and doesn't want isn't known?
When there is no actual God you can make him or her whatever you want to. That's why people feel such a connection with God. Because they can have an intense relationship with him. Relationships are a means of relating to another. When you see that you have things in common with someone you say to yourself 'I can relate to this person, I want a relationship with this person'. By tailor making God to suit yourself, you can relate to him extremely well. You can have a deep and strong relationship because you have so much in common with your values etc...
Now if God was a prick, who randomly killed little children for fun, then you would not be able to relate to him and would probably not believe in him, because this god is not 'your' god.
So you don't worship god at all, you only worship your own personal idea of god.
That's the result of just knowing god, rather than actually reading the books and believing in the actual god, instead of your own personal interpretation. But the problem is the books leave so much up to personal interpretation for this very reason. If the bible actually taught everything straight forward, then there wouldn't be hundreds of different denominations of churches.
so is this all just for christianity? what about other religions?
Also you don't see God in everything. You don't see a rape victim and see the power of God in that. You choose where you want to see God and where you don't want to see god. Once again creating your own personal view of God because you can just pick and choose what you want to believe and attribute to him.
you don't see god in everything because god is not in everything, then we would all be automotons..where god is not, free will given to humans by god is.
Right now your religious beliefs are fulfilling your needs. That's why you aren't going to study the Bible at bible college. Or read books like the God delusion. Or study religion or philosophy at uni. Because right now you don't want to know anything more, because you are happy knowing God the way you know him right now. Truth therefore takes a back seat to having your needs met.
which is one of my most important philosophies in life..
what good is truth if it doesn't one way or another make your life more comfortable?