Bells
Staff member
These questions need to be asked.Needlessly argumentative. You know perfectly well, that "what was she thinking" does not apply to non-consensual sex. I have been a inserting "consensual sex" in virtually every post.
If you are so concerned about the "life" that was created out of sex, why are you only concerned about women who have consensual sex and not others, who are victims of sexual violence? Why does that "life" matter less for women who are victims of sexual violence, but women who consent to sex are somehow irresponsible and thus they waive their rights to their bodies as a result?
Do you understand how, ermm, twisted your argument has been in this thread? Do you understand how sexist it has been? Do you understand that you have spent pages slut shaming women who have consensual sex for reasons other than 'makin' babies'?
So again, why do you refuse to acknowledge all women who seek abortions and their circumstances surrounding that need for said abortions? Why do you focus solely on women who dare to "think that sex is merely recreational"?
Seriously?Could the same thing be argued for a baby one month after birth? "I take responsibility by deciding to end it."
Is it so hard to have a discussion about abortion without resorting to these kinds of scenarios? I mean, are you going for shock value?
Do you understand why the circumstances change after birth? Do you understand that it is no longer residing inside the body of another person? Do you understand the argument of her body at all? Do you understand that personhood cannot be granted to a foetus because it is not a person and because it resides inside the body of its mother, and thus, it is impossible to have competing interests as a result?
Oh yay, more taking my comments out of context. Yay you! Well done.Yep. And if there were a way that she could give up an unborn fetus without ending its life, that would make a good point.
Nope. Once again..I don't either. Which is to my point.
It seems that you are implying this is an OK thing.
Do you want me to use smaller words, perhaps? Because you seem to be having difficulty understanding that "it is her body and not my place or anyone else's place, to tell her what to do with it. It is her body, her life and her decision. It is private and personal matter, between her and her doctor. It is not my place or society's to judge her as being irresponsible for wanting to procure an abortion"..
How you went from that to implying that women are somehow or other saying that 'they can always just get an abortion' or that I am implying this is an okay thing from that, god knows.
Guessing that pretzel still has room for you to twist it.
I beg your pardon? Are you trying to ask questions about my sex life, Dave? Or are you perhaps trying to imply that I feel ashamed for having sex? Oh noes, I have sex for reasons other than procreation. Does this mean you think I should forfeit or have waived rights to my body?...and its another spitball.
If you made an argument based on what I've actually said, without the melodrama, do you think it would still carry weight?
You have made several references to feeling shamed. Do you want to talk?
Do you want me to quote your words back to you? You can just scroll up and read what I quoted from a few posts on just one page in this thread. You want to argue again if I think it will carry any more weight?
Were you possessed when you wrote that?Am I arguing that they engage in an act wilfully and knowingly that would raise the issue of responsibility for another life.
What did she think was going to happen??
Surely the time to decide that she didn't want to take responsibility for another life was before she engaged in creating one.
So this now raises the question:
They've decided to engage in sex
despite the risk of creating a baby
and, if the dice don't fall in their favor
she can decide after-the-fact, that she doesn't want to take the responsibility - the known consequences of her actions
but it's OK, because abortion is always an option as retroactive birth-control.
You don't see just how you are slut shaming women with comments like that?
You didn't actually answer the question.Is this an excuse? "I didn't think of it."
What gray area? It's inside her body. She has her fundamental human rights to her body and if she chooses to abort, it is a private and personal matter, something between herself and her physician. It's not that hard really.True.
But pretending there's no gray area where an unborn child might have rights is not the way to resolve the debate.
Perhaps you should re-read what I have been saying, and what you have been saying and you can explain how or why you think we are in agreement. Otherwise, I'll just assume that you are deliberately misrepresenting my words and taking them out of context in a pallid attempt to appear to be clever with word games.No one (certainly not me) said they should.
I guess that means we're in agreement. Women do not forfeit ALL rights to their bodies.