Frisbinator said:
This one time, this black guy held me up at an ATM with a gun.
SO because of this personal experience, it means that all black people are going to hold me up with a gun doesen't it?
That is such ridiculous, non-sensical bullshit non sequitur, that I can't even believe you posted it.
No it does not, and no rational person would claim that.
Did you bother reading the posts at all?
Neildo said:
Now I don't claim to be psychic or anything and I don't bother to read the paranormal section of these boards...
one_raven said:
Can I prove any of this? Of course not.
Can I tell you what tomorrow's winning lottery numbers are? No.
Do I claim to know what happened, what it means, what's behind it or anything else? Nope.
This certainly does not mean that all psychic phenomena are valid.
Also, I get just as annoyed as any skeptic at people who claim to know exactly how it works and what it all means, with no evidence of it.
At least TRY and be honest with your arguments.
Let's take your analogy and try and make it look a little closer to what was actually being said on this thread...
After the black guy held you up at the ATM, Bill says to you, "That's impossible. I couldn't have happened. Show me your proof. If you have no proof it simply MUST be false. Black guys simply DO NOT do that EVER, so it must be impossible. Look at this statistic %99.99999 of black guys are law abiding citizens, and the
only evidence suggesting otherwise is anecdotal. Skewed eye-witness testimony (you know how unreliable eye-witness testimony can be, there have been COUNTLESS studies on it), unclear video footage (that can EASILY be faked), forensic evidence (that can JUST as easily be planted) and circumstantial evidence. There is not a single shred of verifyable PROOF that any bvlack guy has ever held anyone up. No one has EVER gotten a black guy to hold someone up in lab. There haven't even been any experiments suggested because it is simply impossible to test. In other words, you MUST be either full of shit or mistaken. What, Everyone that has ever lost any money has had it stolen by a black guy now? Don't you see that makes no sense? Are you a moron?"
But, you were there. You SAW him do it. You are SURE he did it. Two other people you were with SAW him do it (though they question the experience now because so may experts told them is was impossible).
What would a reasonable person's response to Bill be?
"Well, I don't know about OTHER black guys. I don't know WHY this out of the ordinary thing happened. I know a lot of black guys, and NONE of them would hold someone up, and I don't know the guy who did this personally, so I can't speak to his personal situation, motive or state of mind... I CAN say, without a doubt in my mind, that this specific incident that I am referring to DID happen."