Why is it not open for discussion? Are you not capable of explaining subjective matters? Or are you just here to waste people's time?See, so now I understand that you are genuinely here to quench your curiosity. There are few explanations, pick one..
1. They want you to stay away from this.
2. They know that you are an argumentative type person and bring in logic and reasons and they won't be able to argue back logically.
3. What did I say in my very early post...The lack of objectivity in defending one's faith in God, is not the weaknesses of their belief, it is built into that, their faith in God is not open for objective discussion.
Devious? How is it devious to take what you said, to wit: "No atheist will ever accept any answer involving reasons and logic..."? I even asked if that was what you meant, so I hardly see any deviousness.See, how devious you attempted by construing my statement that no atheist will accept any answer involving reason and logic....it was in the context of logic behind faith in God because none exist which can appease an atheist.
Now you have qualified it with "in the matter of faith in God". Okay, but I would still like to see you put forth an answer in the matter of faith in God that involves reason and logic.
You have said that no atheist will ever accept one, yet you have yet to present one to even consider.
Are you going to? Or is the entire purpose of your involvement here just to cry foul of those that don't share your view yet have an inquiring mind?
'Cos I'm at a loss to otherwise explain your attitude here.