It would be a long endeavour, but for the sake of this discussion I am willing to answer and say that Medicine Woman is wrong. She cannot in any way lay claim to jesus being fictional. This leaves us on neutral ground - We do not know whether there was a jesus or not, we can merely look at the evidence presented. Now, unfortunately we have countless examples of demi-gods that are claimed to have existed - from Gilgamesh to jesus to thousands of Greek and Roman gods and so on. Surely to believe in any of them we must have serious and valid evidence to persuade us to do so.
To give over your whole life and reasoning for something or someone that does not have credible and supportable evidence pertaining to not only their existence but their claimed divine status is simple foolishness. Unfortunately that is what you're doing right here, right now.
We have evidence to suggest the existence of bigfoot. To believe without doubt in the existence of bigfoot at this time is pointless. It is an excercise in stupidity. I will not sit here however and say "nope, no such thing as bigfoot", because the realm of my knowledge does not expand that far. Perhaps there is a giant bigfooted monkey out there somewhere that would match the evidence and descriptions of bigfoot - but until such time where there is credible evidence to show the existence of such a thing, believing in it is without worth and dishonest. Oh yes, we all have wishes. I for instance wish I was on a spaceship like Voyager travelling through the galaxy. It's a wish I have always had and one that I know will never come to fruition. To believe that I will regardless to what the evidence would suggest is lunacy. It is self delusion - and that is never healthy.
I don't mind being wrong about anything, but to be wrong someone must show that you're wrong. In hundreds of years and nobody has managed to even come close. They have killed to try and be accepted - mass deaths, mass annihilation to try and get support. They have overrun government and daily life, have stuck their nose into all affairs to try and get support. Fruitless. The world shows rapid decline of people willing to engage in and support un-evidenced nonsense. The less educate are all that keeps it afloat right now, and while there will clearly always be less educated people we can only hope that even they move beyond the world's largest act of dumbism.
Show anything of merit to support claims in the existence of a white hippy demi god and you'll have our allegiance. Until then stfu, you're wasting valuable time.