The more he posts, the stupider it gets.
Is stupider even a word... I think you can be 'more' stupid, but surely not stupider?
The more he posts, the stupider it gets.
Prometheus, let me ask you, are you not the teeniest bit jealous of me?
Sure Pete, the fact that we're Speeding Up exponentially, because we're falling. The fact that the Observable Universe is Cooling Down, Expanding and Losing Pressure. The CMBR is merely the outer edges of the Cosmos that have not noticed what the center is doing. Gravity, like air, is elastic.Do you have anything to support your theory?
Is there evidence of this vortex in the CMBR?
What do you think happened before those trillions of years?
Where did that tremendous cloud of hydrogen come from?
How large was it?
Fascinating how your mind works. And yes, that's what they say the Universe is doing - Speeding Up ad infinitum. New ideas, Ferrous Cranus? I know how much you hate them already. Oh,and a large Star will only last a few million years, and Planets can go on for 10 billion years? Are we in agreement?So what's your problem? An explosion is also an accelerating outward expansion that dissipates, right?
Why? Is that what the Universe is supposed to be doing?
New ideas, astrocat. That's what growing and learning is all about.
You seem to be trying to ridicule something.
Are you disputing that a large star will only last a few million years?
Why?
Do you understand that the lifetime of a star depends on its size?
This isn't controversial. It's in the link I posted before.
No no, Pete. This Hydrogen Cloud that formed the Early Universe was a Warm, perfectly Smooth Soup. It evolved gradually, over a great length of time. There was nothing sudden or violent, except maybe when the inside of this cloud went critical and the first star was born. The Cosmos didn't arrive 'Poof,' just like that. They used to think Man arrived 'Poof' just like that, but Darwin showed them different. The Cosmos, like Man, evolved only slowly.Well, I'm not the one pushing a barrow, so I don't see that I need anything. If the Big Bang model is wrong, why would I care?
Your response didn't address any of the questions in my post:
Do you have anything to support your theory?
Is there evidence of this vortex in the CMBR?
What do you think happened before those trillions of years?
Where did that tremendous cloud of hydrogen come from?
How large was it?
It seems like you need a cloud of hydrogen that either appeared *poof*, or was just always hanging around until something (What? And why at that time?) triggered the start of its collapse.
I'm trying my best to answer your questions. I just have Gravity to support my theory, I suppose. Real Gravity, the kind that keeps us tied to Earth. Evidence for the vortex lies in the Ever Lengthening, Speeding Up Streams that seem to compose the Observable Universe. Our own local stream, with us falling into the Hydra Centaurus Super Cluster, but in a way that we can never reach it, for the Hydra Centaurus Super Cluster is falling away from us faster than we are arriving, into an even more massive structure these Seven Samurai called 'The Great Attractor. The great Attractor itself is falling into the Shapely Concentration in the same manner. That's just our local stream.Well, I'm not the one pushing a barrow, so I don't see that I need anything. If the Big Bang model is wrong, why would I care?
Your response didn't address any of the questions in my post:
Do you have anything to support your theory?
Is there evidence of this vortex in the CMBR?
What do you think happened before those trillions of years?
Where did that tremendous cloud of hydrogen come from?
How large was it?
It seems like you need a cloud of hydrogen that either appeared *poof*, or was just always hanging around until something (What? And why at that time?) triggered the start of its collapse.
Glad you got a sense of humour, Prometheus. As a mathematician, it's hard for me to know what you have observed, or how you think the Observable Universe is unfolding. Have you ever heard of the Seven Samurai, as they called themselves, an international group of Scientists active in the mid Eighties? Are you at all familiar with their discoveries? Do you know that the picture of the CMBR taken by COBE, in the Infra Red, the same picture unveiled by Eli Dwek in 1986, showed a perfectly smooth Early Universe, a picture slightly redder at one end than the other? Do you believe the Cosmos started Speeding Up in 1998?Nicely played - from my two word postings on this thread you've managed to figure out that all I want in my life is to be like you, it's just that I can do it because I'm in the grip of the establishment. Actually, scratch that, I'm pretty much given free reign to research what I want and paid reasonably well for it too, so it's not a money issue either. I'm just not smart enough to compete with your work. That's more likely.
If my vote has any weight, I vote for this thread to stay here and open because it's jolly funny.
Please quote the relevant passage to support this contention.Do you believe the Cosmos started Speeding Up in 1998?
That's what it says in Wiki, if you look under Big Bang.
Yes.Is stupider even a word...
Well, I'll retract that bit about God making the Hydrogen just as soon as you can provide a more likely scenario, and no, I don't think Hydrogen is transdimentional. I said 'primping' was. And yes, going around dreaming up Repulsive Forces is Poor Science. Now, Dyddyr, if I got that right, do you have anything Scientific to add to this thread, or are you just here to denigrate? Do you know that human males give off small amounts of NO (Nitrous monoxide?) when sexually aroused? Do you know that females give off pherenomes, that different chemicals are emitted under different situations. Dogs can smell fear? Another chemical, life's full of them. How can you say for sure that these effects are not transdimensional?Well I'm back after my temporary and enforced absence. I notice we've kept up the crackpot intake while I've been away.
Hydrogen is transdimensional...?
God made this hydrogen?
And Astrocat has the gall to claim Pete is making things up and doing "poor science".
Wow.
Just... wow.
Semantics, Simonsays, but definitely not Science.Is stupider even a word... I think you can be 'more' stupid, but surely not stupider?
I refer, of course, to the graph they show of the Cosmos' Expansion (even tho' it's only the Observable Universe that's expanding.) If you go to Big Bang inWiki, I don't see how you can miss it. They don't even allow the possibility that this expansion started only slowly. Could it be they're afraid to? I suspect they are.Please quote the relevant passage to support this contention.
Sure, go ahead, insult me. Just don't get Scientific - I couldn't handle that!
More likely than God?Well, I'll retract that bit about God making the Hydrogen just as soon as you can provide a more likely scenario
No you didn't.and no, I don't think Hydrogen is transdimentional. I said 'primping' was.
Post 263.Astrocat said:and some things, like this creating Hydrogen are trans-dimensional
Can't even copy a name?Now, Dyddyr, if I got that right
I'm always ready to denigrate crackpits.do you have anything Scientific to add to this thread, or are you just here to denigrate?
So what?Do you know that human males give off small amounts of NO (Nitrous monoxide?) when sexually aroused? Do you know that females give off pherenomes, that different chemicals are emitted under different situations. Dogs can smell fear? Another chemical, life's full of them.
You'd have to define exactly what you mean by "transdimensional". If all you mean is that dogs are more receptive to smells than humans, then okay. If you mean something else then you'll have to support it.How can you say for sure that these effects are not transdimensional?
Are we referring to the same page?I refer, of course, to the graph they show of the Cosmos' Expansion
Yet I somehow managed it...If you go to Big Bang inWiki, I don't see how you can miss it.
Glad you got a sense of humour, Prometheus. As a mathematician, it's hard for me to know what you have observed, or how you think the Observable Universe is unfolding. Have you ever heard of the Seven Samurai, as they called themselves, an international group of Scientists active in the mid Eighties? Are you at all familiar with their discoveries? Do you know that the picture of the CMBR taken by COBE, in the Infra Red, the same picture unveiled by Eli Dwek in 1986, showed a perfectly smooth Early Universe, a picture slightly redder at one end than the other? Do you believe the Cosmos started Speeding Up in 1998?
That's what it says in Wiki, if you look under Big Bang. I see they don't even allow the possibility that this Expansion started only Slowly and has since Sped Up. According to Wiki the expansion started Fast, Slowed Down, then Sped Up again... Is this what you believe too?
When did our awareness of the accelerated expansion come into being? Was that 1998?If so, I don't know where he got the idea that accelerated expansion began in 1998. .