#whitesupremacism | #WhatTheyVotedFor
My side is concerned with acquiring genealogical information for the benefit of individuals and society. Your side is concerned with discouraging such pursuits. Best go search your own soul.
No, actually, you're not, and the lie is apparent in that same post:
People seriously ask about their genetic identity in relation to each other all the time, why do suppose there are occupations and fields of study devoted to the practice?
Indeed, this is really important to you:
Warren can learn more about her ancestry by doing more investigation of it, including DNA testing, than she presently knows.
‡
So Warren's knowledge of her ancestry must suffer, other who could benefit from that knowledge in their own genealogical searches must suffer, and students of history in general must suffer, just to spite ....
‡
Then you advocate she should do further research on her ancestry to benefit herself, even if others will try to use it against her.
‡
My side is concerned with acquiring genealogical information for the benefit of individuals and society.
I would suggest saying thank you to a woman named Henrietta Lacks, but you can't, because she's dead. Still, though, you ought to take a moment to thank the woman whose genes were exploited quite literally for decades, and there are millions of cancer survivors whose lives owe honor unto her name.
Spoiler alert: She was black.
Plot twist: Her blackness is beside the point.
"Why do suppose there are occupations and fields of study devoted to the practice?" Well, when it comes to genetics, there is money in it; if there wasn't, there wouldn't be much study. But the big money isn't in the ancestry buzz industry fleecing racists; the big money is in the database of information people are irresponsibly signing over. Someday, the actuarials will die in overdose of bliss and ecstasy using that information to refuse people access to health care, but even more important in the moment is the medical value. When it comes to genetics, the real value will be in overpriced lifesaving technologies. As to genetic identity as an industry, yes, you're right, there are a lot of racists ready to fret about this stuff; that these are your priority doesn't really amaze me, as your sympathy for supremacists is pretty well established.
Meanwhile, here we are, months later, and as much as I think it's a bad idea, this is one of the occasions when doing it for the money can actually be useful. And now that Senator Warren has compromised and will release the evidence, the question remains whether those making such demands will now pursue, with equal vigor, President Trump's one million dollar payoff to the National Indigenous Women's Resource Center. Or perhaps they will skip out, or maybe halfass it, and prove this was about white supremacism the whole time.
____________________
Notes:
@elizabethforma. "By the way, @realDonaldTrump: Remember saying on 7/5 that you’d give $1M to a charity of my choice if my DNA showed Native American ancestry? I remember – and here's the verdict. Please send the check to the National Indigenous Women’s Resource Center". Twitter. 15 October 2018. Twitter.com. http://bit.ly/2RQypRZ