She gets to just walk away because the prosecutor's office gets to decide who they prosecute and who they don't. They're under no legal obligation to prosecute someone who has committed a crime if they don't feel like it. And as a general rule, district attorneys will never prosecute someone for perjury if the perjury involved telling lies that would help convict someone that the DA wants to convict. Like I said, the only time you are ever likely to face perjury charges is if you are caught telling lies that protect someone (usually yourself) that the DA is trying to prosecute.LA why wasnt she punished?
under even curent law (with no specific amendments) there are criminal santions
Definmation (civil suit)
Filing a false report (criminal fallony)
Pergury (asuming she testified in court), criminal falony
so how could she possably just walk away?
LA why wasnt she punished?
under even curent law (with no specific amendments) there are criminal santions
Definmation (civil suit)
Filing a false report (criminal fallony)
Pergury (asuming she testified in court), criminal falony
so how could she possably just walk away?
She gets to just walk away because the prosecutor's office gets to decide who they prosecute and who they don't. They're under no legal obligation to prosecute someone who has committed a crime if they don't feel like it. And as a general rule, district attorneys will never prosecute someone for perjury if the perjury involved telling lies that would help convict someone that the DA wants to convict. Like I said, the only time you are ever likely to face perjury charges is if you are caught telling lies that protect someone (usually yourself) that the DA is trying to prosecute.
At least the same sentence. The poor guy may well have been raped himself repeatedly while in prison. He may have contracted HIV.In my admittedly hot-headed 18-year-old opinion, falsely accusing someone of rape is as vile as actually committing rape.
And should receive the same jail sentence.
I think that they should do some jail time, if the man did jail time for a crime he DID NOT commit then perhaps she should do time for a crime she did commit??
your thoughts:
If women (or men) were to be punished with jail time for accusing someone of rape, it would even further push them away from admitting the truth. Many are ashamed of being raped. Fear of persecution due to a poor legal system, unable to close the book on certain cases, would not be a wise move.
So what do you propose should be done about false accusations? Or do you deny that they occur?
Oh, certainly false accusations occur. If you could prove that the victim made a false accusation with malicious intent, well, then maybe you'd have a case.
Presumably a person would only be punished if the accusation was proven to be false (not if it was merely a case of being unable to prove that the accused was guilty).If women (or men) were to be punished with jail time for accusing someone of rape, it would even further push them away from admitting the truth. Many are ashamed of being raped. Fear of persecution due to a poor legal system, unable to close the book on certain cases, would not be a wise move.