ACLU to the rescue: another Larry Craig story

Is sexual intercourse in a locked public restroom stall a private act?

  • Yes

    Votes: 5 38.5%
  • No

    Votes: 8 61.5%
  • Other (Um ... er ... I ... don't ... know?)

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    13
you REALLY need to go to melbourne, I have seen people going for it lying on the grass in the middle of the park. ....

I'd be throwing a holy hissy fit. My kids don't need to see that. I don't let them watch porn movies, so why would it be ok for them to watch it in the park?

Same with the bathroom stall. People take their kids in there.
 
my point was why should you be charged at all???

i have never seen a cop even care about people going for it in queens park (all though they may get a little peved if you tried to at the war mamorial) and i have seen cops there all the time. Same at the beach and unlike american movies i have never seen a cop charge someone for having sex in a car and i have done it myself a few times with cops fairly near by (did it next to a police station one time)

Its a natural thing to do why worry about it?

Park, theres plenty of space, Car, its your space, beach plenty of space, Bathroom...other people may want to sit on it, without feeling sticky. Also, its a public facility, not a place.
 
I'd be throwing a holy hissy fit. My kids don't need to see that. I don't let them watch porn movies, so why would it be ok for them to watch it in the park?

Same with the bathroom stall. People take their kids in there.

While i don't agree with Asguard's allowance of sex in bathroom stalls, I don't see why couples can't flaunt their desires in parks. If people don't like it, they can petition for "no sex" signs, or move to another park.
 
or they can be arrested or go have sex in a private spot.

Does anyone really need to see a bunch of 16 yrs old boys masturbating as they watch people have sex in the park???
 
this is the problem with religion in the states it makes people afraid of their bodies and some makes people think that natrual things are dirty
 
Some people actually do.. I don't, but people apparently are up for anything.

and I don't wanna watch people have sex in the park. Wanna see a guy go down on another guy in the park? Is there a limit as to what kind of sex you are willing to see in the park? Wanna watch your grandparents?
 
and I don't wanna watch people have sex in the park. Wanna see a guy go down on another guy in the park? Is there a limit as to what kind of sex you are willing to see in the park? Wanna watch your grandparents?

In time, given enough exposure, people will think thats normal. Maybe we should start designating parks.
 
maybe we should start designating their homes. oh wait....

I'm not against public sex, I like public sex, but come on! There's a difference between a blanket out in the woods and a blanket in the middle of a public park. There's a difference between the bed of your truck in the middle of no where and a public bathroom stall.
When you have sex, you'll understand.
 
and I don't wanna watch people have sex in the park. Wanna see a guy go down on another guy in the park? Is there a limit as to what kind of sex you are willing to see in the park? Wanna watch your grandparents?
The dead ones, or the ones who've never met.
I'd have to choose the latter though I am sure it would be strange for my parents.
 
Leges Sine Moribus Vanae. The ACLU seems to have lost sight of its intended purpose.
icon13.gif
 
There isn't enough privacy in a public restroom, for those wishing to avoid the sex.

You can't allow hitting on people, pushing them for sex etc, in a place where they can't avoid it.

Consent, folks. It's why streetwalking should be zoned or banned regardless of the the legality of prostitution, why loud avoidable noise should be banned from residential roads, etc.

The ACLU has a point, but not a case.

And the public health issue is still to be weighed in.
 
Sex columnist and editor of The Stranger Dan Savage weighed in today with a reminder about public sex:

Sigh.

Public sex is hot because it’s… public. It’s risky, you might get caught, someone might see you, blah blah blah. A pair of toilet cruisers may go out of their way to avoid getting caught—they may be quiet and stealthy and creep into each other’s stalls on tiptaptoe—but the off chance that they’ll be heard by someone else in a neighboring stall or seen through the cracks in the stall door by someone walking past is an integral part of the charge.


(Savage)

Part of the problem with desensitizing the American prudishness is that we tend, as a culture, to forego any complicated formulae for wisdom, which leads to a dysfunctional insensitivity to sexual stimuli.

Maybe in other countries bending someone over a park bench and burying it to the hilt is a good idea, and a good show for the kids. But we're Americans, and in general we never really have outgrown our Puritan naivete.

Think of it in a fairly exaggerated term: Fine. So you say masturbation isn't evil. Whatever. I guess that means compelling retarded people to shit on one another is just fine, too.

What I'm getting at is that the American Puritan (lack of) sensibility has trouble understanding certain things. Just because people don't think adultery is a sin against God doesn't mean we thing it's not wrong. If you want to sleep around, don't get married. If you made the mistake of getting hitched, either suck it up and endure your inadequate partner for the rest of your life, or get a freakin' divorce if it's really that important.

And, yes. It really is hard for many Americans to understand that there is a middle ground.
 
seriously though where can the homeless have sex in your sociaty? or do there drinking? that is actually a social justice issue you know
When you're homeless, and living on the street, where to have sex is probably one of your biggest problems. After all, women are just dying to have sex with homeless guys!
greenpoint.jpg

Gimmi some Lovin'!
 
While I would personally object to anyone having sex in a public bathroom, I don't think it should be against the law.
 
While I would personally object to anyone having sex in a public bathroom, I don't think it should be against the law.
I think it should be against the law, but I don't think the police should be setting up sting operations to catch people.
 
Back
Top