Why some patients choose Homeopathy over Allopathy?

Myles said:
Is your medical degree in allopathic medicine ? Nosodes remind me of nostrums which were popular in the Middle Ages. If you wish to use the title Dr., I suggest you are under an obligation to declare what your field of expertise is.
Click to expand...
BHMS = Bachelor of Homoeopathic Medicine and Surgery

What Homeopathic Surgery is I'm still trying to find out. From what I can tell so far it's regular surgery practiced by a homeopath but the only reference I could find was written in 1855. Looks to be an amusing read, even though I only scanned the preface.

http://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/text-idx?c=homeop;idno=AKK5242

~Raithere
 
Raithere said:
You're still referencing articles, not the studies. Do you have any of the studies? Here's the best information I can find on what you referenced:

I don't think this fist one is the same study but a similar study by the same group.





Even if we assume the best results are accurate and ignore the repeated null effect trials this is very thin evidence.

~Raithere
Click to expand...
Thin or thick . Is it evidence or not?
 
Raithere said:
BHMS = Bachelor of Homoeopathic Medicine and Surgery

What Homeopathic Surgery is I'm still trying to find out. From what I can tell so far it's regular surgery practiced by a homeopath but the only reference I could find was written in 1855. Looks to be an amusing read, even though I only scanned the preface.

http://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/text-idx?c=homeop;idno=AKK5242

~Raithere
Click to expand...
Let you explore more about BHMS. And let me see how close you come to know it.
 
Dr. Nancy Malik said:
Thin or thick . Is it evidence or not?
Click to expand...
Without being able to better analyze the study or read critiques of it, it's impossible to tell. But even if the study is methodologically and statistically accurate the population (68) is far too small to draw any strong conclusions. At best it might indicate that further research is warranted. The problem is that the study doesn't stand alone. You'd have to have some large studies with some very strong results to overcome all the null result studies that are out there.

Dr. Nancy Malik said:
Let you explore more about BHMS. And let me see how close you come to know it.
Click to expand...
I tried but I can't find anything informative regarding homeopathic surgery. The best information I found regarding BHMS is here:

http://www.ngu.ac.in/Academic/homeopathic/bhmssyllbus.htm

I will say that I find this comment disturbing, "Hahnemann's Organon of Medicine is the high water mark of medical philosophy."

Here's a link to it in case anyone wants to take a look for themselves:
http://www.homeopathyhome.com/reference/organon/organon.html

As to why, here's an example:

"Whilst paying attention to those circumstances (§ 5) the physician needs only to remove the totality of the symptoms in order to cure the disease.
If all the symptoms be eradicated, the disease is always cured internally also."

This is not only is demonstrably false, but shows that homeopathy is intrinsically symptom oriented.

I found this interesting reference as well, HOMŒOPATHIC MATERIA MEDICA:
http://www.homeoint.org/books/boericmm/index.htm

~Raithere
 
Raithere said:
Without being able to better analyze the study or read critiques of it, it's impossible to tell. But even if the study is methodologically and statistically accurate the population (68) is far too small to draw any strong conclusions. At best it might indicate that further research is warranted. The problem is that the study doesn't stand alone. You'd have to have some large studies with some very strong results to overcome all the null result studies that are out there.

I tried but I can't find anything informative regarding homeopathic surgery. The best information I found regarding BHMS is here:

http://www.ngu.ac.in/Academic/homeopathic/bhmssyllbus.htm

I will say that I find this comment disturbing, "Hahnemann's Organon of Medicine is the high water mark of medical philosophy."

Here's a link to it in case anyone wants to take a look for themselves:
http://www.homeopathyhome.com/reference/organon/organon.html

As to why, here's an example:

"Whilst paying attention to those circumstances (§ 5) the physician needs only to remove the totality of the symptoms in order to cure the disease.
If all the symptoms be eradicated, the disease is always cured internally also."

This is not only is demonstrably false, but shows that homeopathy is intrinsically symptom oriented.

I found this interesting reference as well, HOMŒOPATHIC MATERIA MEDICA:
http://www.homeoint.org/books/boericmm/index.htm

~Raithere
Click to expand...

Good information - thanks.

Yes, it's nothing but a scam that preys on people with little scientific (and medical) knowledge and understand. And of course there ARE patients and "doctors" who actually believe it works. There are also a large number of people who believe in other totally foolish things as well.

I mentioned witch doctors and voodoo earlier. There was an article in the JAMA or NEJM about two or three years ago that compared homeopathy with both witch doctors and voodoo on the basis of the efficacy of each one. It was little surprise that all three had practically identical results - indicating that any improvement was simply a result of psychological influence rather than anything medical or "other-worldly." Therefore it's rather obvious that not one of them is any better than the other two - and that alone should tell anyone ALL they need to know about homeopathy!

Oh - and incidentally, none of them had any effect whatsoever on things like cancer, AIDS or any bacterial or viral infections.
 
Raithere said:
Without being able to better analyze the study or read critiques of it, it's impossible to tell. But even if the study is methodologically and statistically accurate the population (68) is far too small to draw any strong conclusions. At best it might indicate that further research is warranted. The problem is that the study doesn't stand alone. You'd have to have some large studies with some very strong results to overcome all the null result studies that are out there.

I tried but I can't find anything informative regarding homeopathic surgery. The best information I found regarding BHMS is here:

http://www.ngu.ac.in/Academic/homeopathic/bhmssyllbus.htm

I will say that I find this comment disturbing, "Hahnemann's Organon of Medicine is the high water mark of medical philosophy."

Here's a link to it in case anyone wants to take a look for themselves:
http://www.homeopathyhome.com/reference/organon/organon.html

As to why, here's an example:

"Whilst paying attention to those circumstances (§ 5) the physician needs only to remove the totality of the symptoms in order to cure the disease.
If all the symptoms be eradicated, the disease is always cured internally also."

This is not only is demonstrably false, but shows that homeopathy is intrinsically symptom oriented.

I found this interesting reference as well, HOMŒOPATHIC MATERIA MEDICA:
http://www.homeoint.org/books/boericmm/index.htm

~Raithere
Click to expand...


I feel glad that you tried to find about Homeopathy.

Boerick Materia Medica is a popular book among physicians. It also contains a short repertory.

My thesis was on Mental Picture of NOSODES

In India we have only degree level courses in Homeopathy now. Earlier (till around 1995) we have diploma level courses also.

Organon contains the guiding principles of Homeopathy. Homeopathy follows the Hippocrate's "First Do no Harm"

BHMS Graded degree means students who pursue medical degree in Homeopathy after diploma in homeopathy

BHMS Direct degtree means students who purse medical degree in Homeopathy after 12th class.
 
Study they self, if you drink hemlock you will die, but if you eat a daisy you will not. The earth has made chemical compounds and as such has more than likely made many of modern medicines. You have shown no such proof to disprove. Proof must be shown, my proof is that the medicine asprin originated in the bark of the willow tree and was chemically compounded by chemists to make the pill we now know. So in fact modern medicine existed in a natural form before chemists did.
 
homeopathy=NHS voodoo. NHS=death by superbug. Here... we choose to die at home instead. or go private health care.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top