Write4U
Valued Senior Member
No, there is sufficient remedy for illegal acts. There should be an accountability for "conduct unbecoming" as judged by the "civil arm" of the people's representatives.But would you agree that impeachment should not be a political act??
Impeachment does not necessarily result in removal. The remedy might be "censure" or "restriction".
A sitting president cannot be "indicted" and is effectively shielded from criminal prosecution while in office.
The impeached official remains in office until a trial is held. That trial, and their removal from office if convicted, is separate from the act of impeachment itself. Analogous to a trial before a judge and jury, these proceedings are (where the legislature is bicameral) conducted by the upper house of the legislature, which at the federal level is the Senate.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impeachment_in_the_United_StatesImpeachment may occur at the federal level, or the state level. The federal House can impeach federal officials, including the President, and each state's legislature can impeach state officials, including the governor, in accordance with their respective federal or state constitution.
Persons Subject to Impeachment
During the debate in the First Congress on the “removal” controversy, it was contended by some members that impeachment was the exclusive way to remove any officer of the Government from his post,759 but Madison and others contended that this position was destructive of sound governmental practice,760 and the view did not prevail.
Impeachment, said Madison, was to be used to reach a bad officer sheltered by the President and to remove him “even against the will of the President; so that the declaration in the Constitution was intended as a supplementary security for the good behavior of the public officers.”
While the language of section 4 covers any “civil officer” in the executive branch,762 and covers judges as well,763 it excludes military officers,764 and the precedent was early established that it does not apply to members of Congress.
https://law.onecle.com/constitution/article-2/50-persons-subject-to-impeachment.htmlJudges.—Article III, § 1, specifically provides judges with “good behavior” tenure, but the Constitution nowhere expressly vests the power to remove upon bad behavior, and it has been assumed that judges are made subject to the impeachment power through being labeled “civil officers.”