Mafia - the forum game

domesticated om, im not sure what your post means.

As i said i think the cop is a mafia and the PI isnt active so they arnt going to tell us so who will?
 
With skillfull hands, developed from years of training, Enmos the Doctor performed a miracle of modern surgery on the Police Officer (unixgeek13).

Police Officer (unixgeek13) was saved by Enmos.

"How can I possibly top that? I am like a god!", Enmos thought to himself. "I might as well just give up medicine now. I have achieved everything I ever wanted to achieve."

And so, Enmos decided spontaneously to find a new career as a Bartender at the Casino.

This turned out to be very convenient, because as it happened, inzomnia had been studying medicine for years, supporting herself through university with bar work. With a job suddenly opening at the local hospital, and having just graduated yesterday, inzomnia jumped at the opportunity. "I'll make my mark in medicine!", she thought to herself. "And I'll get free seat upgrades from the travel agent, 'cos now I'm a Doctor at last."

----

Notes:
* if the Doctor saves somebody in future, they can talk from the time the Doctor posts the "Emergency surgery" message.
* if Asguard changes somebody's role again (he has one more change allowed), the change is effective from the time he posts his change message. Role descriptions and powers swap. Mafia status stays the same.
 
Asguard said:
domesticated om, im not sure what your post means.

As i said i think the cop is a mafia and the PI isnt active so they arnt going to tell us so who will?
Click to expand...

I re-read the rule. Says the PI's powers don't become active til day 3......it was my mistake
 
The vote deadline is approximately 4 hours from now. It coincides with the start of the Olympic Closing Ceremony, as it happens (i.e. 8 pm Beijing time). Chances are, I won't be counting the votes immediately, but NIGHT will fall within about 2-3 hours of that time.
 
Hey guys, I just woke up and I gotta read all the posts. The first thing I have to say is "Enmos there better be a damn good reason you saved the cop."
 
Challenger78 said:
But why would the mafia kill their own dude ?.. I don't think they're up to that stage of deinformation yet.
Click to expand...

All right, not all the way done reading but I just came across this post. The two most obvious suspects to be offed would be me or Enmos because of our awesome game play, and then the cop. Enmos would be clearly who to kill because he is very smart and is making a bunch of accusations and we have our own secret language. But, most importantly, he is ALSO the town doctor. This makes him invaluable to the townspeople, and the doctor cannot revive himself. It is not a logical killing to off someone OTHER than Enmos, for the reasons I just provided. But, they were faced with a dilemma, off Enmos and everyone knows that he(and I) are correct on our findings, so they killed someone that nobody would suspect(even I didn't, I just made random accusations as always), one of their own, the cop. Knowing Enmos would be forced to save the cop or fear looking like a mafia member in the eyes of the townspeople because of his high prestige role, they killed him and their own members of the mafia tried to convince them. This actually doesn't make much sense to me, so I remove my accusation against Challenger and now say that 11parcal, whom I initially thought was as innocent as Enmos, is more likely to be a mafia member than not.
 
inzomnia said:
Asguard... wait, wait, hold on! That is too big responsibility for me. We could
have discuss it first. I mean, thank you, but I am not sure I am capable of it.
In addition to that, I am on the spot. Giving such responsibility to me just going
to make you suspected. Please give me some time and please reconsider it.
Click to expand...

Soap opera much? Hell, I think I've seen better acting ON a soap opera :rolleyes:
 
USS Athens said:
Unvote: Domesticated om
Vote: Inzomnia

Interesting talk you and Asguard are having there, even though this piece of judgement is based off of pure paranoia.
Click to expand...

everyone unvote inzomnia, as much as a mafia she is we can't risk losing her. She'll play it off as if she is not, if she doesn't save someone vital who dies this night we arrest her then, no sooner.
 
Asguard said:
yes, enmos has GOT to be mafia and i think the cop is too. the way enmos was talking yesterday to put suspicion on EVERYONE but himself with no evidence either way. Then his comments in the other thread were all highly suspicious.

Plus concidering the mafia want to wipe us out and the doc gives us 2 extra people effectivly why wouldnt the mafia take him out, its three for the cost of one

This only makes ANY sence if he is already mafia.

Now why would he bring the cop back UNLESS he was also mafia and that was there plan to alay suspicion

We HAVE to get the doctors roll out of mafia hands and the only "evidence" against inzomnia is what enmos was saying anyway.

Further more her job is relitivly usless especially if the cop is mafia so we can give the mafia that job with no worrys.

Even if he gets arested we havent lost a roll important to the town only one which helps the mafia and preserved the doctor to save US
Click to expand...

Rofl, I was going to respond to this piece by piece but is anyone actually buying any of this? Firstly, theres a reason for that, you(the person you refer to as "I") are the only person in this entire game you can be sure is not a mafia member, Enmos is not a mafia member, why would he raise suspicion about himself. The way he does it is completely logical for those who know he isn't mafia(Enmos and I) but seem like he's deflecting suspicion onto everyone else. Look back 15ish pages, James dropped a hint about how he liked the way Enmos was deflecting attention from himself, do you think James would've been so careless to say that to a mafia member? Let's not forgot how QUICKLY they reached the decision to kill the cop, whether this helps me or hurts me I am not sure, but all we know is that that information is CRITICAL. Your next two points make sense, but my the-cop-is-on-their-side theory covers those. For the fourth point, it doesn't make any sense and even if it did it wouldn't mean anything. The last three don't do anything but incriminate you more, Mr. Mayor.

Maybe I shouldn't be so mean to the guy who said he would moderate my game :p
 
This one I'll break down.

Asguard said:
i dont know about you because nither you nor the former casino operator have done much supicious
Click to expand...
True, the only evidence we actually have is that Steve100 dropped out of the game, which doesn't help point us to either mafia or townsperson very effectively.
my list so far would be

BOH? - not sure about him but he is acting really strange
Click to expand...
Unfortunately, my plans for making everyone suspect me but not enough for arrest haven't been working, and almost nobody thinks I'm not a mafia except for other definitely-not-mafia-ers. Hopefully the mafia won't off me cause I'm just too much fun :D.
Enmos - he has just been to activly acusing everyone and everyone thought he was guilty last night so the mafia would have only gained not lost anything in killing him there for wiping out 3 townsmen with no loss
Click to expand...
Read the it's-the-cop-who-dun-it theory, it encompasses more evidence than yours, so it has to be right.
The cop because if enmos is guilty he HAS to be
Click to expand...
This makes you look quite suspicious, isn't it obvious that Enmos could've just saved the most important role to the townspeople because even if he IS mafia he has no power on that side?
SAM is acting wird but *shrugs* there is no logical motive i can find in her actions which makes me suspicious as well. If she was a townsperson she would have saved one of what should have been the mafia targets. Ie either the doctor or the cop but if all three are dirty she knows there is no danger to either of them
Click to expand...
S.A.M. seems to be taking this game very lightly so she doesn't make logical decisions, that or she's the mafia. He choices are so illogical, but nothing I can say will convince you either way, you guys can decide for yourselves, but most of us have already voted her guilty, while there's a way too high of a change that she isn't mafia, I'm only voting with everyone else this time.
Norsefire im not sure of, he COULD just be saving one of the most important townsperson role or he COULD know that enmos is dirty and be trying to save a fellow mobster
Click to expand...
He's the most important role to the mafia, except he's not on the mafia.
As for inzomnia as i said the only "proof" is that enmos suspected her and he himself is highly suspect
My opinion is that she is inocent or i wouldnt have made her the doctor
I HAD to get the roll away from enmos before he wasted our ownly hope of keeping vital rolls in play and who could i give it to?

Giving it to BOH would be idiotic when im half convinced he's mafia
Click to expand...
So unlike everyone else in this game and the hundreds of guests reading this, you think I'm part of the mafia? More than you think Inzomnia is? You should've given it to Enmos, he's the most trusted. Oh no wait...
the Gun shop proprietor has WAY to much power in that he could take out another one of us when he is arested

giving him my job would be stupid at the moment because he would just change it back

i couldnt give him the travel agent because i suspect she is also mafia

the Entertainer is an unknown and if we made him the entertainer he couldnt be arested for 3 more days

could have made him the gospip but i didnt even think of it to be honest (my bad:()

I herd a romur that the bodyguard can make people mafia which is WAY to dangerious to give to a mafia don
Click to expand...
A rumor? It's mafia..
the lawyer is suspect

That just leaves the taxi driver, the bartender, the newspaper editor and the PI
Click to expand...
PI is much less likely than inzomnia
If the PI became dirty and the cop is dirty we would have no one who could investigate for us

The taxi driver is an unknown but has been suspected by lots of us
Click to expand...
Not really.. but I agree you couldn't give it to him.
The newspaper editor has to much power
Click to expand...
Agreed, if Enmos was actually part of the mafia.
which just leaves the bartender

This is why i chose inzomnia
Click to expand...

Well, there were many better options as I just noticed along with the rest of you.
 
Could anyone do a votes tally for me? I seem to be much too lazy, and also who Om voted for and why the casino owner CCTVed him. As for now, I'm leaving my vote with S.A.M. for the reasons I posted earlier about keeping inzomnia in this game.
 
Summary of votes right now:

Casino owner (USS Athens): 1
Travel Agent (SAM): 7
Doctor (inzomnia): 2
Mayor (Asguard): 1

domesticated om's vote does not count tonight (CCTV).
2 players haven't registered a vote - Cop (unixgeek13) and PI (visceral_instinct)
One player has registered a "no arrest" vote - Doctor (inzomnia)
 
7 SAM
1 Inzomnia
1 USS Athens
1 ME

Domesticated OM was CCTVed in order to stop him voting for SAM because USS Athens wanted to increase the vote to inzomnia

And i disagree with you BTW, as i said i had forgoten about the gospip but i made the choice i did in good faith.

I have read through the whole thread (AND THE OTHER ONE WHERE ENMOS WAS CHEATING) and i belive the chances of him being dirty are MUCH higher than inzomnia

If this fingers me fine but i think your defending enmos fingures YOU more.

As i said IF enmos is mafia then bringing back the cop ONLY makes sence if the cop is ALSO mafia

As i said my list would be
Enmos
BOH
THE COP

Now the other two im not so sure on
i agree that sam could just be being illogical or she could be mafia but im willing to go with the majority on this

as for norsefire im not sure, there is a logical reason to bring back enmos if Norsefire ISNT mafia and he is just saving the most important townsmen OR if they are BOTH mafia and the mafia gets another player

I leave it to you to decide who is right. Of course as i fingered you your going to say im wrong but what the hell:p
 
That was quick :O. Thanks James! Yeah, S.A.M. is definitely not getting out of this one, Norsefire, if you want to save her go ahead, I won't think you're a mafia member just because of it. To our mayor, I'm really not a mafia member, but me and Enmos have a secret language that we use to talk, and I know he's not a mafia member because of it. If I really was a mafia member, would I be soooo bored on nights to start my own game? :D We're also not sure about the cop being a mafia member, but someone else HAS to be a mafia member if he isn't. I think it was you but I forgot my logic and who it was right now, so once I remember I'll post back.
 
Why does that even matter? She wasted a travel voucher, she could've just given it to me which would've made sense but still wouldn't have mattered. I'm not convinced she is mafia, but it's too late now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top