Isn't morality just supersition?

[Balerion]

So are all humans "hard-wired" in exactly, precisely the same way?

See? They'd have to be in order for your ideas of objective morality to be true.

Baron Max

First, they are not all hard-wired the same way. Second, for morality to be objective, they would not all have to be hard-wired the same way.

What it might all mean is that morality is like a scale from 1-to-10, and where each individual is on the scale might depend on the size of a certain gland, or something else of that nature. The fact that so many serial killers and unapologetic murderers share this trait speaks to this point very clearly.

 

[Baron Max]

First, they are not all hard-wired the same way. Second, for morality to be objective, they would not all have to be hard-wired the same way.

And thus their morals would not all be the same. Hence, morality is not objective!

What it might all mean is that morality is like a scale from 1-to-10, and where each individual is on the scale might depend on the size of a certain gland, or something else of that nature.

If it's a scale, then the moralities would be different. And thus, morality is NOT objective.

The fact that so many serial killers and unapologetic murderers share this trait speaks to this point very clearly.

"So many..."? But not all. Thus, morality is NOT objective.

Baron Max

 

[Balerion]

And thus their morals would not all be the same. Hence, morality is not objective!

Wrong.

If it's a scale, then the moralities would be different. And thus, morality is NOT objective.

Why do you bother getting into these discussions when you're obviously not intelligent enough to understand what other people are saying?

The point of the scale analogy is that morality itself is objective, but it is manifested differently by folks because of a physical difference, not an ideological one. That, of course, would speak to morality being objective.

"So many..."? But not all. Thus, morality is NOT objective.

Baron Max

Again, read my last paragraph. If the only difference between the morals of people is a physical difference in the brain, then morality must be objective.

 

[Baron Max]

If the only difference between the morals of people is a physical difference in the brain, then morality must be objective.

I just love "IF" statements ....they're proof all by themselves, ain't they?!

Baron Max