Is it criminal to steal from criminals?

Is it criminal to steal from criminals?

  • Yes

    Votes: 8 61.5%
  • No

    Votes: 5 38.5%
  • Don't Know

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    13
Can we please cut down on the reading material in each post? Your scaring off the lurkers.:D

I do apologize but if one is to validate their side of an argument evidence must be presented. All in all communism or it's biproduct socialism are neither better or worse than capitalism. All are equally terrible. Some just survive longer than the others.
 
I do apologize but if one is to validate their side of an argument evidence must be presented. All in all communism or it's biproduct socialism are neither better or worse than capitalism. All are equally terrible. Some just survive longer than the others.

Ants have survived longer than humans, so have many other animals without money.
 
That is true, power corrupts and aboslute power corrupts aboslutely. Ant and insects..ah hell all other organisms of the different branchs have been surviving on this little blue speck longer than our species has...the question is will Homo Sapiens usher in the 7th mass extinction or will our speices persist until this planet can no longer sustain macro-organisms?
 
I do apologize but if one is to validate their side of an argument evidence must be presented. All in all communism or it's biproduct socialism are neither better or worse than capitalism. All are equally terrible. Some just survive longer than the others.

What's wrong with combining the best of both those worlds?
 
:D we could always try a little better. With the Hippy's Utopian efforts.
 
Last edited:
If it were not a crime to steal from criminals then everyone in prison would lose their property rights to possessions they hold in the outside world. All of their stuff would be subject to confiscation.

In the US this would be illegal. The US Supreme Court has a special topic area devoted to resolving issues concerning prisons and jails. No doubt folks would not be surprised to learn that prisoners in the US are sometimes murdered by guards or other prisoners. So issues like these, and serious injury, are sometimes referred to the Supreme Court. Over the last century or so, a number of cases have resulted in decisions that are now part of settled law. Among these is that prisoner's retain "a constellation of rights" while incarcerated.

In short, no one can deprive a prisoner of life, liberty or property without due process of law. The sentencing court--assuming it lawfully followed due process--could not reasonably dispossess the convict of property except under certain circumstances. For example, a vehicle used by a drug dealer may be subject to impound and auction. But in general, prisoners retain the right to possess property while incarcerated. And their rights are normally fully restored upon completing their sentence.

Under the rationale of the Supreme Court it would be a crime and/or civil tort to take a person's property simply on account of a criminal conviction.
 
Back
Top