Talking about religion, with an air of sophisticated logicalness, is like a bunch of nerds standing outside of a party but being too scared to go inside where the action is. Sometimes you just have to go where the action is and experience it for yourself.
Many atheists have done exactly that, having been raised in or around religious social groups.
I realize how silly it is to pretend you were making an actual point and not simply using the opportunity to call "logicalness" folks "nerds."