Ho hum. I very much doubt one or the other is universally the wrong thing to do. But the issue of "Does who is funding _X_ research compromise it?" often pops-up. There are certainly occasions where it does, but the world isn't perfect, and somebody (company, rich benefactor, government/taxpayer, organization/institution, etc) has to be the sponsor. Each cynic and group of such to pursuing and addressing their own choice for the fly in the ointment when they target something suspicious (to them).
- - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Who Should Fund Science?
https://quillette.com/2023/11/04/who-should-fund-science/
EXCERPT: State investment in science is certainly nothing new, but what is fascinating is how easily it is now accepted as the de facto means of spurring scientific innovation. Pew polling confirms that, while government funding does not necessarily inspire trust in science, the public is far less likely to trust scientific findings when funded through an industry source. Additionally, 82 percent of Americans believe government investment in scientific research is usually worthwhile.
Many Western governments failed to respond adequately to the COVID-19 pandemic, so it is understandable that policymakers want to invest heavily in scientific research. After all, should we not ask our state leaders to invest more than ever in innovation in case a worse threat arises? But when considered on the merits of its economic, philosophical, and historical arguments, the claim that governments should be responsible for funding scientific research turns out to be a counterproductive myth... (MORE - missing details)
_
- - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Who Should Fund Science?
https://quillette.com/2023/11/04/who-should-fund-science/
EXCERPT: State investment in science is certainly nothing new, but what is fascinating is how easily it is now accepted as the de facto means of spurring scientific innovation. Pew polling confirms that, while government funding does not necessarily inspire trust in science, the public is far less likely to trust scientific findings when funded through an industry source. Additionally, 82 percent of Americans believe government investment in scientific research is usually worthwhile.
Many Western governments failed to respond adequately to the COVID-19 pandemic, so it is understandable that policymakers want to invest heavily in scientific research. After all, should we not ask our state leaders to invest more than ever in innovation in case a worse threat arises? But when considered on the merits of its economic, philosophical, and historical arguments, the claim that governments should be responsible for funding scientific research turns out to be a counterproductive myth... (MORE - missing details)
_
Last edited: