animal experimention - mistreating animals

Originally posted by spuriousmonkey
how could your proof the existence of 'soul'.
Click to expand...
If you mean 'how could I prove it?' then I have no idea. I haven't been arguing it exist, just that we don't know it doesn't and that we shouldn't make assumptions.
 
Originally posted by WellCookedFetus
Emotions are simply impulse of different pathways in the brain and the use of different endorphins. Pain, pleasure, happiness, angry, frustration, depression are link directly to specific sections of the brain and levels of specific endorphin uses. So no there is no magical soul making us who we are... there is only a physical soul made of neurons, dendrites and axons.
Click to expand...
Perhaps you would like to show us your proof of this. It is an irrational prejudice an no more. The jury is out. Better brains than ours have been and still are working on this with no success yet.
 
Originally posted by Canute
If you mean 'how could I prove it?' then I have no idea. I haven't been arguing it exist, just that we don't know it doesn't and that we shouldn't make assumptions.
Click to expand...

I am assuming that you know perfectly well that things do not exist in science if they cannot be shown to exist in some scientific manner, be it directly or indirectly. We can therefore make the assumption that it doesn't exist, since it doesn't fall into the realm of the natural world...apparently.
 
Originally posted by WellCookedFetus
No there is no different between humans and animal, if you mean to say that human have a distinct group of characteristics that no other animal has combined then you are correct. Humans have advance and complex language, advance cognitive skills and opposable thumbs, beside that we act and think like animals, we have the same emotions, desires and impulses as animals, we may have some distinct abilities that have allowed us to conquer the world for are own selfish greedy animals disires, but when it comes down to it we are nothing but talking monkeys!
Click to expand...
I agree, although we can't prove it yet. We seem to also agree that animals are conscious of emotions and desires.
 
Originally posted by WellCookedFetus
Ants also have a distinct group of characteristics that combined no other animal has... does that make them "special"?
Click to expand...
Of course it does.
 
Atoms existed before the microscope because theory predicted they existed base off evidence. No theory yet supports a logical structure of existence for a soul, other then the physical neuron based one. So which is more probable: our soul is made of gray matter or it’s some magical sprit energy thingy that we have that no other animals?
 
Originally posted by spuriousmonkey
actually no...the microscope was invented long before the atom theory was postulated if I am not totally mistaken.
Click to expand...

oh yeah, I remember now...well, you know what mean, right?
 
Canute,

Sorry I was not talking to you :( it was directed at DrNeroCF

But for the questions directed at me I advice a class in general psychology or a psychology text book.
 
well, it seems like a soul isn't a physical structure, and probably isn't some magical thing...what about being a term? the essence of man, so to say...not so much as a soul is what makes us different, but what makes us different is dubbed our soul
 
Originally posted by DrNeroCF
well, it seems like a soul isn't a physical structure, and probably isn't some magical thing...what about being a term? the essence of man, so to say...not so much as a soul is what makes us different, but what makes us different is dubbed our soul
Click to expand...

Then the assumption (based on what?) is that we are different (from what) in a particular manner (what manner?).
 
So a soul is the ability to think constructively as well as implement and develop complex solutions to problems (all of technological development for example)? Well then that makes retards and the handicapped soulless.
 
heh, are ya'll gonna keep buggin me until I come up with the right aswer of what a soul is? honestly I don't know, I hope ya'll aren't assuming I know. I know I don't know, I'm just offering my thoughts on what a soul might be, hoping that combined with whatever ya'll are saying gets us that much closer. Fetus that's a good point, but do we know what is going on in the mind of a retard?

(I don't think this thread is going to end until we scientifically describe exactly what a soul is, heh)
 
Originally posted by spuriousmonkey
I am assuming that you know perfectly well that things do not exist in science if they cannot be shown to exist in some scientific manner, be it directly or indirectly. We can therefore make the assumption that it doesn't exist, since it doesn't fall into the realm of the natural world...apparently.
Click to expand...
Yes, this is the classic circular argument. Things that are not scientific are not science, and things that are not science are not scientific. This of course means that everything that exists is scientifically observable and scientifically explicable, I don't think. It's an old argument, attempted in dozens of ways, and it doesn't wash. If you look the the fallacy is obvious.

I'm not trying to prove the opposite view to yours. I'm just saying that NEITHER view can be proved true or false by science. In scientific terms it is an undecidable question. So you are closing yourself off to an important aspect of YOUR existence if you close your mind to the other possibility. You shouldn't do this without better reasons than you've given here.

It would be wrong to think that we're just arguing useless metaphysics here. We really, really do not know whether 'souls' (which by some definitions is synonymous with consciousness), exist or not, or who has them and who doesn't. This does not mean that they do not exist, it really and actually does mean that we don't know.

Of course you can believe what you like. But there is no 'scientific view' on this matter.
 
DrNeroCF,

That like asking if we know what’s going on inside the mind of an animal! We are saying that since there is no parameter that any of us can think of to even define a soul as well as prove its existence it therefore in all likelihood it does not exist.

So lets us recap here (since moderator close threads that go to off topic) from what I understand many say that if animals have a "soul" then we might need to rethink how we treat them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top