The common Christian belief that Allah is in fact an ancient Moon god isolated for use in a monotheistic religion does not work out.
"Before the creation of Islam, Mohammad's tribe of Arabs believed in many gods. Their Moon god, the most hallowed of all their gods, was called Allah. Thus Allah in the Muslim religion is a fake god and Mohammad a fake prophet."
My responce is:
"Before the arrival of Christianity in Latvia, Latvians believed in many gods (many Latvians still do). Their King of Gods, the most hallowed of all their gods, was called Dievs. Thus Dievs in the Latvian bible is a fake god and Jesus is a fake saviour."
Explanation of that is: When Christian invaders of Latvia tried to convert the population, they tried a common strategy used for the conversion of Pagans: isolate their King of Gods or their most hallowed god, try to make him seem like the same god as the Christian God, and give him the same name so a Pagan reading the Bible for the first time will just think that the "Dievs" (or the name of whatever god is used) in the Bible is the same as the one in their religion, until the Bible slowly wedges them away from Paganism.
I believe Mohammad used a similar tactic: highlight similarities between the Islamic Allah and their Moon god, give him the same name, and people will be more willing to convert.
Feedback?
(btw, there is a Chick tract on this, that's what gave me this idea. and yes, that is a widely held belief)
"Before the creation of Islam, Mohammad's tribe of Arabs believed in many gods. Their Moon god, the most hallowed of all their gods, was called Allah. Thus Allah in the Muslim religion is a fake god and Mohammad a fake prophet."
My responce is:
"Before the arrival of Christianity in Latvia, Latvians believed in many gods (many Latvians still do). Their King of Gods, the most hallowed of all their gods, was called Dievs. Thus Dievs in the Latvian bible is a fake god and Jesus is a fake saviour."
Explanation of that is: When Christian invaders of Latvia tried to convert the population, they tried a common strategy used for the conversion of Pagans: isolate their King of Gods or their most hallowed god, try to make him seem like the same god as the Christian God, and give him the same name so a Pagan reading the Bible for the first time will just think that the "Dievs" (or the name of whatever god is used) in the Bible is the same as the one in their religion, until the Bible slowly wedges them away from Paganism.
I believe Mohammad used a similar tactic: highlight similarities between the Islamic Allah and their Moon god, give him the same name, and people will be more willing to convert.
Feedback?
(btw, there is a Chick tract on this, that's what gave me this idea. and yes, that is a widely held belief)