Katazia said:
Statitsics in Perspective
What seems more important is that more people are not joining the major religions than are joining them. We should consider both Christianity and Islam as failures in this respect
Kat
Yes, they have plateaued, or even gone into decline. But when you consider that the Industrial Populations are shifting demographics from rural to urban, you could expect a decline in religiousity. To see whether the Religions are actually failing, you would need to see whether they are seriously behind the curve -- losing rural membership which is usually considered secure, while not retaining whatever percentage would seem normal in an industrial environment.
But, yeah, Catholicism is losing ground from a tactical error it made in regards to Ecumenism -- to appease Protestants the Catholic Church stopped emphasizing that the Protestant Churches were beyond the Pall of Grace. This attracted absolutely no new Conversions, because what Protestant in his right mind would go from the easy layed back Saved and Keep Sinning
Fundamentalist framework to the much more strict Catholic discipline? None! But when Catholics were made to feel that it no longer made a serious difference, they started going Protestant too. If the Prot Church was closer then it was handier -- and then they wouldn't have to go to Confession, and they wouldn't have to kneel so often BUT IT WOULD STILL BE 'CHRISTIAN'. We lost badly. They should find the Bishop who made the decision and put him on an 80 day fast.
And it does matter -- the difference between Catholic and prot. Our Lady has never appeared in Apparition to a Protestant. And the Protestants have never had their first Saint. The Bishops should never have let up on stressing that there is a Huge Spiritual Difference.