Why is my brother different from me?

Magical Realist

Valued Senior Member
We come from the exact same DNA. So how is it that I am different from my brother? What causes this huge variability in how the two strands of my parent's DNA fuses together? Also, how much DNA is the same between me and my brother?
 
The only way to determine how much DNA you and your brother share is to analyze it. This is quite possible and it's done every day. This is how they resolve paternity suits, for example.

However, any two humans share the vast majority of their DNA. I'm not certain what the figure is, but I'm certain that if one person has less than, say, 95% of the same DNA that you have, then he is not actually a human person, but another species of ape. Even a banana tree has almost 50% of the same DNA that you have. All living things--animals, plants, fungi, algae, bacteria and archaea--are descended from the same ultra-simple living organisms that arose several billion years ago. The differences among the species are generally due to errors in reproduction, for example due to the effect of cosmic rays. We call these mutations. This is why all organisms share so much of their DNA. You can't toss the molecules around and reassemble them just any way you want, or you'll end up with something that is simply not alive.

If it turns out that all humans share 98% of their DNA, then that only leaves 2% that you and your brother inherited specifically from your parents, differentiating you genetically from other family groups. In this case, probability indicates that, on the average, two brothers would share 99% of their DNA.

Again, please bear in mind that my figures are all estimates based on things I vaguely remember. I could be way off, in which case all humans might share as much as 99.9% of their DNA, or as little as 97%.

If a real biologist jumps into this discussion, you can believe his figures and ignore mine. ;)
 
You have half of your mother's chromosomes (23/46), and half of your father's chromosomes (23/46).

So does your brother.

They're probably not exactly the same 23 chromosomes from each parent, unless you were identical twins.
 
The only way to determine how much DNA you and your brother share is to analyze it. This is quite possible and it's done every day. This is how they resolve paternity suits, for example.

However, any two humans share the vast majority of their DNA. I'm not certain what the figure is, but I'm certain that if one person has less than, say, 95% of the same DNA that you have, then he is not actually a human person, but another species of ape. Even a banana tree has almost 50% of the same DNA that you have. All living things--animals, plants, fungi, algae, bacteria and archaea--are descended from the same ultra-simple living organisms that arose several billion years ago. The differences among the species are generally due to errors in reproduction, for example due to the effect of cosmic rays. We call these mutations. This is why all organisms share so much of their DNA. You can't toss the molecules around and reassemble them just any way you want, or you'll end up with something that is simply not alive.

If it turns out that all humans share 98% of their DNA, then that only leaves 2% that you and your brother inherited specifically from your parents, differentiating you genetically from other family groups. In this case, probability indicates that, on the average, two brothers would share 99% of their DNA.

Again, please bear in mind that my figures are all estimates based on things I vaguely remember. I could be way off, in which case all humans might share as much as 99.9% of their DNA, or as little as 97%.

If a real biologist jumps into this discussion, you can believe his figures and ignore mine. ;)

Keep in mind, you have to separate the autosomal DNA (that which is NOT carried on the X and Y chromosomes) from the specific DNA that dictates how we look/gender/etc.

http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~laetoli/degree.html

Degrees of Relation and Number of Genes Shared
Estimates of how many human genes exist range from 25,000 to 100,000. As the sequencing of the human genome nears completion, the consensus is closing in on the suprisingly low figure of around 30,000. The following table uses this number to estimate how many of an individual's genes are shared by their relatives.

Of course, any individual's mother and father share over 99% of their autosomal[2] DNA (the DNA not carried on the X and Y[3] chromosomes[1]). This means that the individual shares much more of each parent's DNA than the 50% indicated by the table.

Thus the table shows us that 50% of our DNA is directly received from each parent and not that the genes inherited from one parent are entirely different to those inherited from the other.

What the table also shows us is that, beyond 7-degrees of relation, the number of genes shared in this manner is rather few. By extension, an individual's sixteenth-century, 13 times great grandfather has less than a half chance of providing a single autosomal gene to that individual, assuming that there is no other relationship between the two.

In terms of genes, there isn't much significance in taking your family tree back to Norman times for, at that distance, our genetic heritage will long ago have merged into the population's gene pool[5]. In fact, ignoring the DNA that all human's share, it's possible to be genetically unrelated to a direct but distant ancestor even when hanky-panky can be ruled out!

There are, however, three genetic lineages which can be traced back much further.

The first is your pure maternal line, i.e. your mother's, mother's, mother's etc. lineage. This is because you inherit a small fragment of DNA, called mitochondrial DNA[4], solely from your mother.

The second is a man's pure paternal line. This is because a man inherits his Y-chromosome[3] solely from his father. This does not apply to women as they do not have a Y-chromosome.

The third are specific genetic markers that can be pinned down to specific populations. An example of this is the gene associated with cystic fibrosis, the origin of which can almost certainly be traced back to European populations. Most such genetic markers will not be associated with disease although, to date, these have been the best studied.

The amount of DNA involved with first two of these lineages is rather little compared to the rest of our DNA. However, because of its unique status, it is often analysed for genealogical purposes. The third group of lineages represent a much larger, more diverse, number of genes, but, as genetic typing advances, I believe it will play a much larger role in genealogy.
 
We come from the exact same DNA. So how is it that I am different from my brother? What causes this huge variability in how the two strands of my parent's DNA fuses together? Also, how much DNA is the same between me and my brother?

It is worth pointing out - you would only come from the exact same DNA if you are Maternal twins (that is, one egg fertilized by one sperm that split into two zygotes).

Two different sperm can have two different DNA: When sperm or eggs are created, half the DNA of your body goes into it - however, it's like taking 46 cards (representing the 46 chromosomes) and shuffling them, then drawing 23 cards (the 23 chromosomes each reproductive cell, Egg or Sperm, carries) randomly to get a stack of cards (one reproductive cell)
 
Back
Top