WillNever
Valued Senior Member
There's a rather alarming trend that has surfaced recently on the forum and especially in some of the natural sciences forums. I tend to try and make very informative, helpful, and easily understood posts to people in those forums who I can tell don't know a great deal about the subject. I do this for a couple reasons. (1) I like to talk about these subjects and (2) I like to be helpful to people who want to learn. Here's an example of that.
However, often, and without any provocation whatsoever, certain people jump into the thread thinking they know better and immediately start acting rudely by insinuating that others are not making sense or are missing details. Usually, this is done under the guise of making a correction to something I said -- except that almost every time, their correction is wrong or simply a competing idea of their own.
Here's a very recent example of what I am describing. In this example, "Name Withheld" is the person acting inexplicably rude. And remember, this is their first post in the thread in response to my first post in the thread as well. I edited some excess statements out so you can see the overall picture, but nothing was taken out of context.
That <Name Withheld> prefers a less recognized definition (which may or may not be as legitimate) seems immaterial to the fact that I wasn't posting "nonsense" (not to mention that I was 100% right). That comes from a medical dictionary right there. So why the rude labeling of "nonsense?" What makes people think it's okay to be so rude to complete strangers on the forum? What do they get out of it?
However, often, and without any provocation whatsoever, certain people jump into the thread thinking they know better and immediately start acting rudely by insinuating that others are not making sense or are missing details. Usually, this is done under the guise of making a correction to something I said -- except that almost every time, their correction is wrong or simply a competing idea of their own.
Here's a very recent example of what I am describing. In this example, "Name Withheld" is the person acting inexplicably rude. And remember, this is their first post in the thread in response to my first post in the thread as well. I edited some excess statements out so you can see the overall picture, but nothing was taken out of context.
WillNever said:As well, cancer is defined as malignant cell growth. Left unabated, this is always harmful. Just because some cancers (like prostate cancer) are very slow growing doesn't mean they aren't harmful.
Name Withheld said:Nonsense. Cancer can be benign.
S.A.M. said:I thought benign tumour means "not cancer".
Name Withheld said:Yeah, okay. I have no doubt that there will be terminology nuances between academic and clinical texts.
At this point I provided proof positive that my definition has a great deal of support behind it.WillNever said:You are gravely wrong. Benign tumors are not considered "cancer," although they can be lethal. It is wise to verify what you are saying before rudely calling other people's very accurate and very well-evidenced statements "nonsense." Try learning to be less rude, if at all possible.
I have the professional literature to back me up. I pulled my definition straight from a med-surg book. And here's what my medical PDA says, which basically trumps anything else here, as it represents what is said academically and in practice: Screenshot taken directly from Taber's medical dictionary on my PDA.
That <Name Withheld> prefers a less recognized definition (which may or may not be as legitimate) seems immaterial to the fact that I wasn't posting "nonsense" (not to mention that I was 100% right). That comes from a medical dictionary right there. So why the rude labeling of "nonsense?" What makes people think it's okay to be so rude to complete strangers on the forum? What do they get out of it?
Last edited: