News From Gaza

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sadly true, The fact that Israelis are not blood thirsty killers, places you at extreme disadvantage, to People like the Palestinians who will kill their children to kill you.

In that case maybe they would share their peaceful weapons with the Palestinians?
In 2007 (up to 29 December), Israeli forces killed 373 Palestinians (290 in Gaza , 83 in the West Bank ), among them 53 minors. By comparison, in 2006, 657 Palestinians were killed, including 140 minors: 523 in Gaza , 134 in the West Bank . In 2007, about 35 percent of those killed were civilians who were not taking part in the hostilities when killed. This is a reduction in comparison with the number of casualties who did not participate in the hostilities in 2006, which was 54 percent, (348 persons).

Palestinians killed seven Israeli civilians (three in a suicide attack in Eilat, two in Sderot by Qassam attacks, and two by gunfire in the West Bank ). This is the lowest number of Israeli civilian casualties since the beginning of the Intifada. Palestinians also killed six Israeli security forces. In 2006, Palestinians killed 17 Israeli civilians.
 
So you think we should have forced Yugoslavia to stay in one piece? Should we have prevented the Cheks and Slovaks from gaining independence seperately?

"Segregation" is just Sam's description of two nations living side by side independantly. She is against this notion because it would mean Jews would get self determination alongside Palestinians, something Sam, with her selective morality, would have none of. Therefore its only natural she support one large state, since Arab birth rates would guarantee Palestinian dominance.

Sadly, Sam represents the Palestinian version of the Zionist settlers, who crave for the whole cake, and do not believe in compromise.

So Zionism is secular and asking to remove religious discrimination is an evil concept?

If the situation were reversed EXACTLY what would you think?
 
The US hired the Nazis after everyone knew what they had done and closed its doors to the Jews instead.

They hired a few rocket scientists. Not exactly the picture you're presenting.

That's the goal of the media war, the perception of perfectly equal injustice.

Interesting point.

I think the Palestinians should ask Israel for citizenship. Problem solved. They won't attack each other if its all one country.

Haw! That wasn't the case 80 years ago. In fact, reality is the exact opposite of your scenario. Any religious minority in an islamic country knows this.

Just like they naturally do, and have done, all over the world, and all through time- absent the bitterness of forced ethnic segregation and the international tensions it causes, people get along much better everywhere. When the apartheid ends, the real reconciliation can begin, and not a day sooner.

And when the apartheid is an integral part of the dominant religion? What then? It's been 1400 years without real reconciliation. Reconciliation would appear to have little to do with it; nor is the absence of separation any guarantor of peace, either immediate or eventual. Except the peace of the grave or abject subjugation, I suppose.

So...asking to remove religious discrimination is an evil concept?

In my experience of our debates, it appears to depend. When I ask for it, your response suggests that it is, in fact, evil, although it would appear obviously a good thing.
 
Amnesia is a wonderful thing
So is genetic disfunction.

Just ask the Palestinians: Poster children, all.

Hmm. Muslims all. What's up with that?

OK, some token Christian representation in amongst them.

Do the math.
 
S.A.M. conveniently forgets about Operation ODESSA, that is the popular name but it was the routes to and through Egypt and the Middle East through which the Nazis escaped Nuremburg.

Nazi War Criminals in the Middle East? - Associated Content
May 31, 2007 ... ODESSA was a secret group that provided escape routes for Nazi ... After World War II, Egypt offered refuge for hundreds of fleeing Nazis. ...
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/262391/nazi_war_criminals_in_the_middle_east.html


Numerous former SS officers held key positions in the secret service and political police in Egypt. These included:

Joachim Däumling, former Gestapo chief in Düsseldorf, and later engaged in SS operations in Croatia. He was employed to set up the Egyptian secret service along the lines of the SS Reichssicherheitshauptamt (Himmler's Reich Security Main Office); he was helped by the former Gestapo chief of Warsaw who organised the security police.
SS General Oskar Dirlewanger, chief of the infamous SS penal brigade;
SS Major Eugen Eichberger, battalion-commander in the Dirlewanger brigade;
SS Colonel Leopold Gleim, chief of the Gestapo department for Jewish affairs in Poland;
SS Lieutenant Colonel Bernhard Bender, Gestapo official in Poland the USSR, whose knowledge of Yiddish enabled him to penetrate Jewish underground organisations;
SS General Heinrich Selimann, Gestapo chief in Ulm;
SS Major Schmalstich, Gestapo liaison officer to French collaborationists and organizer of Jewish transports from Paris to Auschwitz;
SS Major Seipal, Gestapo official in Paris;
SS General Alois Moser, a war criminal who was involved in the extermination of the Soviet Jews in the Ukraine;
SS officer Johannes von Leers (1902-1963), who had been responsible for anti-Semitic campaigns at Goebbels' propaganda ministry;
SS officer, Alois Brunner, who had held senior position in Adolph Eichmann's "Jewish Department", and is now believed to be living under the protection of the Syrian secret police in Damascus;
SS Major Walter Bollman, Nazi espionage chief in Britain before the war, and also involved in crimes against humanity and genocide against the Jews of the Ukraine;
SS official Louis Heiden, who was transferred to the Egyptian press office during the war;
Franz Bartel, and "old fighter" in the early days of the NSDAP in Germany, and Gestapo officer;
Walter Birgal, an SS officer from Leipzig;
Erich Bunz, a former SA major and expert in the "Jewish Question";
Albert Thielemann, a regional SS chief in Bohemia;
SS Captain Wilhelm Böckler, a war criminal who had precipitated in the liquidation of the Warsaw Ghetto;
Wehrmacht General Wilhelm Fahrmbacher, who took over the central planning staff in Cairo . . . .

Added to this were a number of former Nazi officials and sixty military experts, mostly former Waffen-SS men, who assisted in the training of the Egyptian army. Several of them were also linked in 1958 with the then Algerian government-in-exile. At least 200 German and Austrian scientists and other personnel were deployed in the new aircraft and missile centre at Helwan, where new staff physician was Dr. Hanns Eisele, SS Captain and medical torturer in the death camp at Buchenwald. Goodrick-Clarke says that President Gamal Abdel Nasser was "well disposed" towards the Nazis, all the more because they wished to take part in the destruction of Israel. The presence of so many Nazi's in Egypt under the Nasser regime was exposed in the world press in October 1962, and precipitated a crisis in the Israeli government (who had ordered MOSSAD to make try and kill several of the Nazi's), and embarrassment in West Germany, over the exposure of postwar Nazi collaboration with the Nasser regime.

Not surprisingly, the few remaining Egyptian Jews fled. From population of 75,000 Jews in 1948, by 1974 only 350 remained. In 1956, 4000 Jews were expelled, after being forced to renounce all property rights and financial claims. In 1957, all Egyptian Jews not in "continuous residence" since 1900 were deprived of citizenship. In 1960, many synagogues were closed down, along with Jewish orphanages, schools, hospitals and old peoples homes; and in 1967, all Jews in official positions were dismissed, with many more tortured and expelled.
 
Buffalo Paste: "Not surprisingly, the few remaining Egyptian Jews fled. From population of 75,000 Jews in 1948, by 1974 only 350 remained. In 1956, 4000 Jews were expelled, after being forced to renounce all property rights and financial claims. In 1957, all Egyptian Jews not in "continuous residence" since 1900 were deprived of citizenship. In 1960, many synagogues were closed down, along with Jewish orphanages, schools, hospitals and old peoples homes; and in 1967, all Jews in official positions were dismissed, with many more tortured and expelled."

Surely that had nothing to do with the creation of Israel, right, BR? Did you know there were Jews thriving all over the Mideast right before there was an Israel? Hmmm, kinda makes you stop and think for a second, doesn't it?

OK, your second's up. Get back onto your zionazimurdercycle and ride.
 
Buffalo Paste: "Not surprisingly, the few remaining Egyptian Jews fled. From population of 75,000 Jews in 1948, by 1974 only 350 remained. In 1956, 4000 Jews were expelled, after being forced to renounce all property rights and financial claims. In 1957, all Egyptian Jews not in "continuous residence" since 1900 were deprived of citizenship. In 1960, many synagogues were closed down, along with Jewish orphanages, schools, hospitals and old peoples homes; and in 1967, all Jews in official positions were dismissed, with many more tortured and expelled."

Surely that had nothing to do with the creation of Israel, right, BR? Did you know there were Jews thriving all over the Mideast right before there was an Israel? Hmmm, kinda makes you stop and think for a second, doesn't it?

OK, your second's up. Get back onto your zionazimurdercycle and ride.
zionazi???
 
In that case maybe they would share their peaceful weapons with the Palestinians?

So Zionism is secular and asking to remove religious discrimination is an evil concept?

If the situation were reversed EXACTLY what would you think?



Zionism is the national movement of the Jews, simple as that. Just as Palestinians deserve the right of self determination seperate from other people, so do Jews. You can backtrack and twist it all you want, but I find your selective morality on national rights to be deeply hypocritical.
 
Buffalo Paste: "Not surprisingly, the few remaining Egyptian Jews fled. From population of 75,000 Jews in 1948, by 1974 only 350 remained. In 1956, 4000 Jews were expelled, after being forced to renounce all property rights and financial claims. In 1957, all Egyptian Jews not in "continuous residence" since 1900 were deprived of citizenship. In 1960, many synagogues were closed down, along with Jewish orphanages, schools, hospitals and old peoples homes; and in 1967, all Jews in official positions were dismissed, with many more tortured and expelled."

Surely that had nothing to do with the creation of Israel, right, BR? Did you know there were Jews thriving all over the Mideast right before there was an Israel? Hmmm, kinda makes you stop and think for a second, doesn't it?

OK, your second's up. Get back onto your zionazimurdercycle and ride.




So the ethnic cleansing of 800,000 Jews is Just and Understandible because Israel exists? In hypewaders mind, everything done by Arabs is understandable under the "circumstances", therefore legitemate. On the other hand, every Jewish action is "unprovoked".


Lets be honest here, every crime by one Party in this conflict has a previous crime by another party to attribute to it. It is not one sided, and Israeli actions were just as much a response to previous Palestinian actions. I could claim, for instance, that:

- Palestinians were evicted due to the Arab intent to destroy the Jewish state, so "legitimate". I just Hypewader'd the crime.

- The Stern gang SHOULD have been created, due to the Arab pogroms of 1920 and 1929 which were totally unprovoked. Ive just "legitimized" the Stern Gang using Hypewader methods.


This can go on and on, so stop whitewashing Arab crimes simply because it doesn't fit your world view.
 
In 2007 (up to 29 December), Israeli forces killed 373 Palestinians (290 in Gaza , 83 in the West Bank ), among them 53 minors. By comparison, in 2006, 657 Palestinians were killed, including 140 minors: 523 in Gaza , 134 in the West Bank .



Now that's dishonest, Sam. Many of the deaths were a result of Palestinians killing Palestinians, and a Minor can just as well be a 16 year old with an m-16, something very common in Gaza.



In 2007, about 35 percent of those killed were civilians who were not taking part in the hostilities when killed.




This statistic is starting to smell bad, since previous estimates Ive read put the number at over 12:1 militant/civilian ratio. Do you have a source for it?
 
Surely that had nothing to do with the creation of Israel, right, BR? Did you know there were Jews thriving all over the Mideast right before there was an Israel? Hmmm, kinda makes you stop and think for a second, doesn't it?

So...Israel is created and it's now ok to expel Jews. Because the conflict has no religious basis.

Sure does make you stop and think. Some people even just stop thinking altogether.
 
Now that's dishonest, Sam. Many of the deaths were a result of Palestinians killing Palestinians, and a Minor can just as well be a 16 year old with an m-16, something very common in Gaza.

No these are exclusively Israeli caused deaths and air raids don't distinguish between infants and teens.



This statistic is starting to smell bad, since previous estimates Ive read put the number at over 12:1 militant/civilian ratio. Do you have a source for it?

B'tselem.
 
Zionism is the national movement of the Jews, simple as that. Just as Palestinians deserve the right of self determination seperate from other people, so do Jews. You can backtrack and twist it all you want, but I find your selective morality on national rights to be deeply hypocritical.

You can't have a national movement that discriminates against people who were already living there, for not being Jewish. Just like you can't have a national movement that discriminates against people for not being Aryan.

I always wonder, what did the Zionists think when they decided to hold their national movement? What did they think were they going to do with the Palestinians who lived in the place they wanted their Jewish nation?
 
You can't have a national movement that discriminates against people who were already living there, for not being Jewish. Just like you can't have a national movement that discriminates against people for not being Aryan.

I always wonder, what did the Zionists think when they decided to hold their national movement? What did they think were they going to do with the Palestinians who lived in the place they wanted their Jewish nation?

Yeah some 4 million or so palestinians in their respective territories!..nothing compared to the abuse and treatment carried out on a daily basis in your own country by your own people!!
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/06/0602_030602_untouchables.html
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top