... Bedouin tribes in the Negev have been removed from their ancestral lands by a determined Israeli parliament and a compliant religiously defined justice system which declares Bedouin encampments illegal and shepherds the tribes into Israeli-built towns and villages. ... In Israel, the Bedouin are largely unemployed, are forcibly removed from 'illegal' settlements, and are 'required' to adapt to Israeli (i.e. Western European) ways of living. This means a dislocation, of course, from their ancient cultural traditions, the attendant breakdown of social structure, unemployment, boredom, crime, drug and alcohol use, and the usual dynamic seen anytime an ancient culture is systematically attacked by an external (well-meaning) culture. ...
It doesn't care that it is creating a bigger problem that will come back to bite it in the ass one day. These people have been manipulated and coerced because Jews are so paranoid they think every Arab has to be made to live where it can keep an eye on them. This is the true rationale - creating space for European Jews by displacing as many Arabs as it can, by hiding them out of sight and out of mind. ...
I agree with most of your post, but not the parts I made bold. I think Israel is solving their Bedouin problem (by slow genocide) and that is hardly "well-meaning" but of course packaging this genocide as an effort to aid these primitive people have schooling, better health care, etc. is a smart cover for this genocide. To reduce the birth rate, men can leave for work or army service and they must as there are no jobs in the camps - only meager hand-out of food, which is strange to the Bedouins.
I posted earlier on this (after watching a CNN documentary showing the Israelis bulldozing down the crude huts the Bedouins built in the desert.
See:
http://www.sciforums.com/showpost.php?p=1843505&postcount=1169)
To make these less-nomadic / partially settled in desert Bedouins cease trying to farm, Israel sprays their crops with herbicides. Most have now given up and accepted their forced confinement in the "settlement camps," where they can neither farm nor even support a few animals with grass - as these sites were chosen for their poor soil and little available water. (Israel delivers some water by tank trucks.) Conditions in the camps are poor, but much better than the Nazis provided in their concentration camps, except perhaps psychologically as, unlike the Jews in Germany, the Bedouins are not adjusted to high density urban environments.
From post 790:
“…these smart people {The Israelis} learned how to get away with the extermination that the world was to "Never Again" let happen. Israel could and did exterminate the Negev Bedouins more quickly {than the Palestinians} (at least their culture has been exterminated even if only about 80% of the Bedouins are dead or dispersed to other lands, at present.) as they were already self-isolating and without any allies. …”
From post 768:
“…Clearly peace and security is not the current Israeli objective. Extermination of two different peoples appears to be, but the Israelis did learn from Hitler not to try to do it too quickly. Unless to a people so cut off from the rest of the world and modern communication that no one will notice. - I.e. the Negev Bedouins are being more quickly exterminated than the Palestinians and few are noticing, certainly no one is acting, not even saying "Never Again;" but if they did, the only meaning it could possibly have is: "Never again will there be Negev Bedouins" or any restoration of their already destroyed culture. That culture began long before Abraham founded the Jewish one. …”
From post 764:
“…Israeli's extermination of that {Bedouin} culture is already complete and only about 10% of the former population is still alive in the seven concentration camp "cities." Israel has forced the majority of Negev Bedouins into these camp/cities and the surrounding guards prevent most from escaping back to the desert. Some do slip out past the guards on moon less nights and try to live the old way in the desert: Subsistence farming with a few animals, but Israel routinely bulldozes their simple shacks into rubble and has been spraying their gardens with herbicide since 2002, so their number are also dwindling. (Some even “voluntarily” return to the camp/cities when hungry enough and their animals are dead from lack of grass. It is amazing how effective modern herbicides are.) In about 15 years more the "final solution" to the Bedouins occupying land Israelis want and are setting in will be complete. - I.e. all the Bedouins will have fled or be dead.
Hitler was not able to do as effective job as Israel is doing on the Negev Bedouins; however, don't expect me to congratulate Israel when Israel’s “final solution” to the Negev Bedouins problem is 100% done. (Morally these exterminations are the same.)
I think it reasonable for the Palestinians to expect the same, especially as they, unlike the Bedouins, are throwing more than a few stones as their contribution to the chain of retaliations. It will take longer, as there are more Palestinians, and they have allies in other countries, but in 100 years or so the present policy of High Kill ratios, cutting off energy for water pumps, etc. may work as a “final solution” to the “Palestinian problem.” (Assuming, which I doubt, that none of their allies supplies them with a very-lethal, biological aerosol of a highly contagious agents first. If that should happen, it probably means the extermination of the Israelis. – Their low birth rate and lower numbers decreases the chance some genetic immune/ resistant Israelis will survive to repopulate.) …”
From post 802:
“…The Negev Bedouin's claim to the Negev (and Sinai, before being forced out of it) land has been unintentionally supported by Israeli excavation for new Israeli settler homes. That digging discovered a Bedouin graveyard more than 5000 years old. And thus documented an “occupational claim” approximately 100 times older that Israel has existed, but still there were no recorded deeds or other records on file in Israel, so the Bedouins did not own the land the new Israeli settlers were building their home on from the Israeli POV. …”
I am not “anti-jewish” but strongly disagree with many policies of the state of Israel, as do some Jews. I have suggested alternative defensive means* to protect ALL Israelis instead of Israel’s High-Kill ratio policy, which needs to permit a few Israelis to be killed annually by the terrorist.
------------------------
*See:
http://www.sciforums.com/showpost.php?p=1124159&postcount=115
Now I will return to my mainly lurking mode.