phoenix2634
Registered Senior Member
Well, after doing some reading (1600+ posts 
), and some thinking...
The only person I think I can trust is unixgeek 13 -- was the original cop, who could investigate others, was the the first mafia target...which makes sense if he's not mafia. Then VI was the next mafia target...which again makes sense. So unixgeek13, I really don't think is mafia.
Next, I thought about who voted for whom, and if there was any consistancy in voting for non-mafia members. That led to domesticated om and nietzschefan. Domesticated om voted for Enmos, S.A.M., Norsefire, and Norsefire. Nietzschefan voted for SAM, SAM, Norsefire, and Norsefire. In addition, niestzschefan has yet sway the vote, and we now know that those who were voted to be arrested weren't mafia. All that means to me is that while both may have legitmately not known who was innocent, it still seems suspicious to me. And nietzschefan a little more so, simply because he hasn't used his power.
Then I started thinking about the role changing, stuff and am a little surprised at Challenger78's urgency in implicating Asguard. My own thoughts are that Asguard was being manipulated by Inzomnia. I am somewhat suspicious of Challenger, because Challenger first suggested to Inzo, to revive the mayor. Although to be fair, Challenger did bounce back and forth a couple of times between reviving VI or Asguard. Of course, Inzo(who was mob) jumped on it to revive Asguard if Asguard made BOH the cop.
Further it was suggested by BOH that it was possible that the mafia hit the original cop, picked up on by Asguard, who thought at the time that it could have been to eliminate Enmos from suspicion. I'm not sure what I'm thinking here anymore... Probably that Asguard was manipulated into putting the power of the Doctor into the hands of the mafia, and upon doing that, further manipulated into putting the power of the cop into the hands of the mafia. In terms of who I'd suspect is mafia based on this would be, BOH, followed by Challenger78, and then Asguard.
Now if, BOH is mafia, then you'd have to consider how accurate the information regarding USS Athens being innocent is.
That leaves skaught, who voted for Inzo, SAM, norsefire, and norsefire each day.
And finally myself, who I know isn't mafia -- but that really doesn't mean much to anyone else. Everyone would say they aren't mafia even if they are mafia.
I guess if I had to rank who I suspect is most likely mafia to who is most likely innocent it would be:
1. BOH 2. Challenger78 3. nietzschefan 4. domesticated om 5. skaught 6. USS Athens 7. Asguard 8. unixgeek13 9. phoenix2634
So as of right now, I'm thinking I'm going to vote to arrest Challenger78, in part because if I'm right, then the knife killer who's 2 for 2 in taking out the mafia, could easily kill off BOH, and so no need to waste a vote on BOH. But then again because I'm still uncertain and don't want to be arresting an innocent town member I may vote no arrest. :shrug:
), and some thinking...The only person I think I can trust is unixgeek 13 -- was the original cop, who could investigate others, was the the first mafia target...which makes sense if he's not mafia. Then VI was the next mafia target...which again makes sense. So unixgeek13, I really don't think is mafia.
Next, I thought about who voted for whom, and if there was any consistancy in voting for non-mafia members. That led to domesticated om and nietzschefan. Domesticated om voted for Enmos, S.A.M., Norsefire, and Norsefire. Nietzschefan voted for SAM, SAM, Norsefire, and Norsefire. In addition, niestzschefan has yet sway the vote, and we now know that those who were voted to be arrested weren't mafia. All that means to me is that while both may have legitmately not known who was innocent, it still seems suspicious to me. And nietzschefan a little more so, simply because he hasn't used his power.
Then I started thinking about the role changing, stuff and am a little surprised at Challenger78's urgency in implicating Asguard. My own thoughts are that Asguard was being manipulated by Inzomnia. I am somewhat suspicious of Challenger, because Challenger first suggested to Inzo, to revive the mayor. Although to be fair, Challenger did bounce back and forth a couple of times between reviving VI or Asguard. Of course, Inzo(who was mob) jumped on it to revive Asguard if Asguard made BOH the cop.
Further it was suggested by BOH that it was possible that the mafia hit the original cop, picked up on by Asguard, who thought at the time that it could have been to eliminate Enmos from suspicion. I'm not sure what I'm thinking here anymore... Probably that Asguard was manipulated into putting the power of the Doctor into the hands of the mafia, and upon doing that, further manipulated into putting the power of the cop into the hands of the mafia. In terms of who I'd suspect is mafia based on this would be, BOH, followed by Challenger78, and then Asguard.
Now if, BOH is mafia, then you'd have to consider how accurate the information regarding USS Athens being innocent is.
That leaves skaught, who voted for Inzo, SAM, norsefire, and norsefire each day.
And finally myself, who I know isn't mafia -- but that really doesn't mean much to anyone else. Everyone would say they aren't mafia even if they are mafia.
I guess if I had to rank who I suspect is most likely mafia to who is most likely innocent it would be:
1. BOH 2. Challenger78 3. nietzschefan 4. domesticated om 5. skaught 6. USS Athens 7. Asguard 8. unixgeek13 9. phoenix2634
So as of right now, I'm thinking I'm going to vote to arrest Challenger78, in part because if I'm right, then the knife killer who's 2 for 2 in taking out the mafia, could easily kill off BOH, and so no need to waste a vote on BOH. But then again because I'm still uncertain and don't want to be arresting an innocent town member I may vote no arrest. :shrug: