Mafia 2

Hey! What's with the two votes for me?

Obviously, I've been trying to help the town.

Right now, I'd advise everybody to vote for Challenger78. BlueMoose's vote for me may be revenge, but Challenger78 has no reason to vote for me other than being mafia.

And where's the police officer?

If the police officer investigated me today, I ask him to ensure that the results are published for all to see. In fact, regardless of who was investigated, I want to see the result.

Unvote: BlueMoose
Vote: Challenger78

BlueMoose: if you're not mafia, please change your vote to Challenger78.
 
James R said:
Hey! What's with the two votes for me?

Obviously, I've been trying to help the town.

Right now, I'd advise everybody to vote for Challenger78. BlueMoose's vote for me may be revenge, but Challenger78 has no reason to vote for me other than being mafia.

And where's the police officer?

If the police officer investigated me today, I ask him to ensure that the results are published for all to see. In fact, regardless of who was investigated, I want to see the result.

Unvote: BlueMoose
Vote: Challenger78

BlueMoose: if you're not mafia, please change your vote to Challenger78.
Click to expand...

Disagree. If I have the capability to vote; Vote: James R8.
 
James R said:
Hey! What's with the two votes for me?

Obviously, I've been trying to help the town.

I'd advise everybody to vote for Challenger78 or BlueMoose. They must be mafia.
Click to expand...

Me mafia, how is that ? My two post of alien jokes makes me mafia ?
I dont for sure are you mafia or not, for my self I know I´m not mafia.
Now you are attacking Challenger too, looks like you know whom isnt mafia
so you must be one ! The Cop should investigate you as soon as possible,
or investigate me, I´m fine with that.
 
James R said:
Hey! What's with the two votes for me?

Obviously, I've been trying to help the town.

Right now, I'd advise everybody to vote for Challenger78. BlueMoose's vote for me may be revenge, but Challenger78 has no reason to vote for me other than being mafia.

And where's the police officer?

If the police officer investigated me today, I ask him to ensure that the results are published for all to see. In fact, regardless of who was investigated, I want to see the result.

Unvote: BlueMoose
Vote: Challenger78

BlueMoose: if you're not mafia, please change your vote to Challenger78.
Click to expand...

The lack of town roles makes it harder for me to suspect someone, So I voted in you to see your reaction.. and I was proven right. Instrad of asking why I voted for you and offering reasons not to, you instead vote me back.
 
Yes Challenger, why vote James ? This is hard, for now...

Unvote: James R
 
Challenger78, how would knowing the town rolls actually help know who to arest?
they are handed out at random as are the mafia rolls

the only difference this time is that the town rolls are not independent from mafia status
 
Nevermind Challenger, you have posted your reasons already I see.
 
CheskiChips said:
Disagree. If I have the capability to vote; Vote: James R
Click to expand...

I can see this game going the same way as the last one. The townspeople automatically want to vote out anybody who talks too much. Definitely that's what the mafia will try to do.

In the last game, SAM was voted out for talking too much at the start, and she wasn't mafia. Meanwhile, the real mafia members, who weren't posting much, didn't attract any attention and so stayed in the game.

BlueMoose said:
Me mafia, how is that ? My two post of alien jokes makes me mafia ?
Click to expand...

I edited the post you're referring to, BlueMoose.

As I said, maybe you wanted to vote for me for revenge, but Challenger78 has no possible reason other than that he is mafia.

I dont for sure are you mafia or not, for my self I know I´m not mafia.
Now you are attacking Challenger too, looks like you know whom isnt mafia
so you must be one !
Click to expand...

This makes me more than a little suspicious of you, I must say.

You don't know that Challenger78 is not mafia - you can't possibly know that. That's if you're a townsperson. But if you are mafia, then you know who all the other mafia are.

In fact, I think that, most likely, you and Challenger78 are both mafia. You want to protect him (and yourself) by voting for me, because you're worried that I will deduce who the mafia are.

The Cop should investigate you as soon as possible, or investigate me, I´m fine with that.
Click to expand...

Apparently, the cop has already investigated somebody. We need to know the results of that investigation before the vote deadline.

---

Right now, I urge the townspeople to vote for BlueMoose, based on his statement that he somehow knows that Challenger78 is not mafia. The only way he can make such a definitive statement is if BlueMoose himself really is mafia and is trying to protect Challenger78.

Unvote: Challenger78
Vote: BlueMoose

Please, townspeople, don't make the mistake of voting me off just because I've posted a few times. Consider BlueMoose's post - it's the best evidence we have for somebody being mafia so far - and it points the finger right at BlueMoose and Challenger78.
 
Aah shit... I remember this tension coming back from the last mafia game..
Argh...
James, I voted you, to see your reaction, and while it's still highly suspicious, (If you denied it flat,It would have been a dead giveaway that you were mafia), You could have at least asked why, but then you pointed the finger back at me.
 
You people are just targeting those that talk the most, and actually want to trust people based on their reactions. Look at the way James denied my accusations.
Since I can't trust no one

Unvote:James R
Vote: No Arrest
 
CheskiChips said:
Wouldn't the people who voted "No Vote" be likely candidates for Mafia?
Click to expand...

You might be right. There's certainly no reason for any townsperson to vote "No arrest".

So, we have:

Betrayer0fHope
Vaiorom
11parcal

who have all voted "No arrest" at this point.

I'd like Challenger78 to defend himself as to why he isn't mafia. I'd like to trust you, Challenger78, but right now I'm finding you suspicious. Please tell me who you think might be mafia.

I've unvoted BlueMoose now because he unvoted me. I'll assume he is trustworthy for now. But I'll find it very hard to trust anybody who votes for me.

Based on the info I have right now (which is very slender), I think the above 3 people are potential mafia, and neither BlueMoose nor Challenger78 are in the clear yet as far as I am concerned.

Challenger78: convince me that you're not mafia, and I'll unvote you.
 
CheskiChips:

You're guaranteed to be innocent - is that right?

If that is the case, I suggest that we form a voting alliance. The people we know are innocent need to work together to counter the mafia vote - they will definitely try to vote out people they see as a threat. You're an obvious target, and I'm talking far too much for my own good.

So, who do you think we ought to vote for?
 
James R said:
Hello all,

This town looks like a good place to set up my computer sales business.

I'm opening a little shop in the main street, right next to the gun shop. I'm sure I'll be safe with the gun shop owner protecting his premises - and hopefully mine as well!

If anyone wants to buy a cheap copy of Vista, imported direct from my supplier in China, just let me know.

Ah, I can just see the cash starting to roll in! This town will be a fantastic place for me to stay. Crime problem? What crime problem? I don't know anything about that.
Click to expand...

Town - Gun shop proprietor, takes out another person when they die

Does this potentially give enough rise to question him actually being Town?
 
Basically, I vote people to see their reactions, I made the mistake of trusting other people to sway my judgement last game. Right now I trust no one but myself. That is why I voted you. Plus, the people in positions of business are usually mafia, Although that logic may have not been applied here, this has to have some resemblance to RL. Mafia=money=shops etc. Last game I believe at least one of the higher positions were mafia.
Although If the shop thing was your own storyline, I apologize, but given the situation, I can't fully trust you.


Judging from your reaction, I initially thought you were mafia, but your reasoning for Bluemoose changed my mind somewhat, but, If you're mafia, you could be sowing division between me and bluemoose, Who I haven't voted for yet, seemingly because the only common factor between me and him is you. He voted for you, and no offence but YOU started it.
 
CheskiChips what are you talking about, he is a townsperson but if he his killed or arested he will have a free shot at someone else. Now being a townsperson he will probably kill the most likly mafia but thats not 100% garentied. Its his decision and if you wrongfully arest him you could just piss him off:p
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top