Greatest Thinker, in Your Opinion

R

Redoubtable

Guest
Which famed or not-so-famed cogitator, of all the memorable luminaries of human history, would the reader deem as most worthy of praise?
Please give adequate justification and explantion. Maybe I can learn something new and endearing.

I'm feeling ambivalent at the moment and will reply to my own question in due time.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Eienstien.. not for E=MC2 , but for the fact he was a lot of fun.
And mainly for the line -
"My religion is my fascination of the universe"

(sorry its not elaborate but its that simple for me )
 
I'd say Newton for his thoughts on gravity. To actually see what was on his mind would be so good!!!

Even now, to actually see what gravity is, is quite hard to envisage, for example; In a 1 dimensional environment then gravity would just be pure weight, i.e. it is heavy and pulls downards, whereas in our universe gravity must be a force that turns in on itself!!

Explaining what I am trying to express is not easy to do in words, so I will use some diagrams. If anyone can explain how gravity actually works I will be impressed!!

----- - Ignore these lines, they are just to make the diagram work

_________---_____ -Here gravity is a weight that is just heavy,
---------------\/-------- - and it pulls downwards


In our environment the force must pull in on itself, i.e. be collapsing! It is pulling in on itself from all sides!!

----\/
-->O<
----/\


If Earth has gravity because of it's large mass, then what is it actually pulling on, to keep us on the ground??! Gravity must work by turning things in to nothing!!!
 
Last edited:
I have a feeling it was a pre-civilization era human. People nowadays are tainted with so much idea pollution, not to mention the extreme cynicism and apathy that have become so prevalent. Sometimes a blank slate has advantages, and the arena of novel thought I believe is one of them. When you think you know something sometimes you don't bother exploring other possibilities, or are lead into familiar areas out of comfort.
 
Who is the greatest thinker of all time, in your opinion, blankc; that's what this thread is about.
 
Freud was also a landmark writer, in my opinion. One of the greatest!
 
Thank you for giving this to us Repo Man! I have started to read it, but it's late. I will read it tomorrow though, and I will post my thoughts then. :)
 
hmmmm

Jean Paul Sartre...
much too depressed to explain why however..

:)
 
I do not have an opinion on who I think the greatest thinker is or was. However, I do believe almost anyone can think great things. It just requires effort. :)

James Sibley
 
You'd have to break this down into categories of thinking to avoid a thirty-way tie. But let me add a name that should be on the list: Carl Jung. He dug down to the kernels of wisdom in Freud's work, threw out the rest, integrated it with what we had already learned during fifty thousand years (or whatever) of being able to talk to each other, and rebuilt psychology into a discipline worthy of being called a philosophy.
 
Originally posted by prozak
Evola

Does reading his work make you bleed from your eyes?

My list:

Ayn Rand
Robert A. Heinlein
Friedrich Hayek
Aristotle
Plato
Ann Coulter
David Horowitz
 
Galt: Ayn Rand?
:rolleyes:
And which Heinlein? The incredibly liberal one he was in the early years, or the incredibly conservative one he was in his later years?


Okay, my list, not in any particular order and certainly incomplete...
Kant, for his ideas on justice;
Voltaire, More and Erasmus, for their contributions to the Enlightenment and Humanism;
Bhudda, for bhuddism (duh!);
Ghandi and King, for showing that force is not the only way to achieve your goals;
Galileo, for reasserting the place of experimentation over doctrine;
Russell, for the thoughts mentioned above;
Adams, for showing capitalism isn't a zero-sum game;
Hippocrates, for the code of ethics used by doctors;
Darwin, for evolutionary theory;
Harvey, for bringing experimentation and observation back to medicine;
Aristotle, for inventing sophistry and debate, along with the other great Greek philosophers;
Euclid, for codifying all of the mathematics of his day and providing a model for most of the rest of the mathematical world;
Bacon, for his contibutions to philosophy (hell, even for Novum alone)
Einstein, for the concept of relativity;
Bohr and his contemporaries, for the concept of quantum mechanics;
Maxwell, just for his equations on electromechanics;
Marx, for modern communist theory;
Descartes, for his work on the fundamentals of modern philosophy;
The "founding fathers" for documents like the Bill of Rights and for founding a country on the principles of the Enlightenment - even if the last fifty years have been a sincere disaster...;
Gutenberg, Bell, Marconi and Berners-Lee for improving the speed of inter-human communication.
 
I do not have an opinion on who I think the greatest thinker is or was. However, I do believe almost anyone can think great things. It just requires effort.
So very true, and surely one of the purposes of us being born with a brain; we can choose to do what we like.
You'd have to break this down into categories of thinking to avoid a thirty-way tie. But let me add a name that should be on the list: Carl Jung. He dug down to the kernels of wisdom in Freud's work, threw out the rest, integrated it with what we had already learned during fifty thousand years (or whatever) of being able to talk to each other, and rebuilt psychology into a discipline worthy of being called a philosophy.
Also very true! I have started to read one of his books and it's intersting to say the least. Some may consider him (and Freud) slightly far fetched, however the more that I myself learn, the more I can see how right they both are!
 
Originally posted by EI_Sparks
Galt: Ayn Rand?
:rolleyes:

Of course. What, are you a commie or something? :p

Originally posted by EI_Sparks
And which Heinlein? The incredibly liberal one he was in the early years, or the incredibly conservative one he was in his later years?

He always had a Libertarian streak in him.

Free love, low taxes and lots and lots of guns. How can you go wrong with that?
 
Back
Top